Combining Graphical and Algebraic Approaches for Parameter Identification in Latent Variable Structural Equation Models

Ankur Ankan,Inge Wortel,Kenneth A. Bollen,Johannes Textor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2302.13220

2023-02-26

Abstract:Measurement error is ubiquitous in many variables - from blood pressure recordings in physiology to intelligence measures in psychology. Structural equation models (SEMs) account for the process of measurement by explicitly distinguishing between latent variables and their measurement indicators. Users often fit entire SEMs to data, but this can fail if some model parameters are not identified. The model-implied instrumental variables (MIIVs) approach is a more flexible alternative that can estimate subsets of model parameters in identified equations. Numerous methods to identify individual parameters also exist in the field of graphical models (such as DAGs), but many of these do not account for measurement effects. Here, we take the concept of "latent-to-observed" (L2O) transformation from the MIIV approach and develop an equivalent graphical L2O transformation that allows applying existing graphical criteria to latent parameters in SEMs. We combine L2O transformation with graphical instrumental variable criteria to obtain an efficient algorithm for non-iterative parameter identification in SEMs with latent variables. We prove that this graphical L2O transformation with the instrumental set criterion is equivalent to the state-of-the-art MIIV approach for SEMs, and show that it can lead to novel identification strategies when combined with other graphical criteria.

Methodology,Statistics Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the parameter identification problem in structural equation models (SEMs) containing latent variables. Specifically, the authors focus on how to apply existing graphical methods to identify parameters in these models, while these graphical methods were originally designed for causal graph models (such as DAGs) without considering measurement error. Since in many practical applications, measurement error is ubiquitous, for example, blood pressure recording in physiology or intelligence measurement in psychology, traditional graphical methods are often not directly applicable to SEMs containing latent variables. The paper proposes a new method. By converting latent variables into observed variables (i.e., "Latent - to - Observed conversion" L2O), it is possible to use existing graphical criteria to identify parameters in SEMs. This method can not only be comparable to the existing Model - Implied Instrumental Variables (MIIVs) method, but also can identify more parameters in some cases. In this way, the paper aims to fill the gap between the graphical model literature and the SEMs field, and provide a more flexible and effective parameter identification strategy.