K. Knakkergaard Nielsen
Abstract:For decades, it has remained an open question, whether two dopants in the $t$--$J$ model bind in the strongly correlated regime of small spin couplings versus hopping, $J \ll t$. Here, we investigate this problem in Bethe lattice structures with Ising coupling $J_z$, and mainly focus on the case of a coordination number equal to 4. The special geometry circumvents subtle effects in regular lattices, but importantly still contains the non-trivial dependency on the rotational symmetry and particle statistics. It, furthermore, allows us to reach numerical convergence, and we conclusively answer whether binding occurs or not. In particular, we find that the rotationally symmetric $s$ waves unbind below $J_z \simeq 0.3 t$, which we unveil is tied to Pauli blocking of symmetrical hole configurations. This is further substantiated by the fact that holes in a bosonic spin environment shows strong -- superlinear -- binding at low $J_z / t$. Additionally, higher rotational fermionic $p$ and $d$ waves partially overcome the blocking, are perfectly degenerate, and bind for all $J_z / t$. In the strongly correlated regime of $J_z \ll t$, this binding occurs sublinearly with scaling $\sim t (J_z / t)^{3/2}$.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore whether two holes can form a bound state in an antiferromagnetic Bethe lattice. Specifically, the research focuses on whether two dopants will be bound in the t - J model when the spin - coupling J is much smaller than the hopping term t (i.e., the strong - correlation limit). This problem is of great significance for understanding the many - body effects in strongly - correlated systems, especially the microscopic mechanism of high - temperature superconductivity.
### Research Background and Motivation
Over the past few decades, the question of whether two dopants will form a bound state in the t - J model has remained unresolved. This problem is not only related to the motion behavior of dopants in a quantum spin environment but also involves their pairing instability at a finite density, thus providing key insights into the microscopic origin of high - temperature superconductivity. However, even in low - energy effective models such as the t - J model, the existence of a bound state in the strong - correlation limit (J ≪ t) is still an unsolved mystery. With the new opportunities of quantum simulation experiments of ultracold atoms in optical lattices, this classic problem has regained people's interest.
### Main Findings
1. **Bound State in Bethe Lattice**:
- The author studied the Bethe lattice structure with Ising coupling Jz by numerical methods, especially when the coordination number is 4.
- The results show that in an antiferromagnetic Bethe lattice, two holes will always form a bound state. The formation mechanism of this bound state is that a constraint string composed of flipped spins appears between the two holes.
2. **Influence of Particle Statistics**:
- For bosons, the binding energy shows a super - linear dependence, that is, in the strong - correlation limit (Jz ≪ t), the binding energy increases rapidly with the increase of Jz/t.
- For fermions, due to the Pauli exclusion principle, the rotationally symmetric s - wave state will be unbound when Jz/t is below a certain critical value (about 0.3t). This is because in a fermion system, the symmetric hole configuration is prohibited by the Pauli exclusion principle.
3. **Characteristics of Higher - Order Rotational States**:
- Higher - order rotational states (p - wave and d - wave) partially overcome the Pauli blocking effect and always show a bound state, and these states are degenerate.
- In the strong - correlation limit (Jz ≪ t), the binding energy of these higher - order rotational states shows a sub - linear dependence, that is, ~t(Jz/t)^{3/2}.
### Methods and Techniques
- **Model and Hamiltonian**:
- The research is based on the t - Jz model, which contains the nearest - neighbor hopping t and Ising - type spin coupling Jz.
- Through the Holstein - Primakoff transformation, the system is described in the form of holes and spin excitations.
- **Rotational Subspace**:
- Utilizing the discrete rotational symmetry of the system, the Hamiltonian is decomposed into its rotational subspaces, and the binding energy in each subspace is calculated.
- **Matrix Representation**:
- By constructing the matrix representation of the low - energy two - hole state, the properties of different rotational states, especially the binding behaviors of s - wave, p - wave, and d - wave, are studied.
### Conclusion
This research clearly answers the question of whether two holes will be bound in the antiferromagnetic Bethe lattice in the strong - correlation limit. The results show that the existence of a bound state highly depends on the statistical properties of particles. Bosons show strong binding, while fermions will be unbound under certain conditions. In addition, higher - order rotational states (p - wave and d - wave) partially overcome the Pauli blocking effect and always show a bound state. These findings provide a new perspective for understanding the many - body effects in strongly - correlated systems, especially in terms of the microscopic mechanism of high - temperature superconductivity.