Abstract:A graph class $\mathscr{C}$ is called monadically stable if one cannot interpret, in first-order logic, arbitrary large linear orders in colored graphs from $\mathscr{C}$. We prove that the model checking problem for first-order logic is fixed-parameter tractable on every monadically stable graph class. This extends the results of [Grohe, Kreutzer, and Siebertz; J. ACM '17] for nowhere dense classes and of [Dreier, Mählmann, and Siebertz; STOC '23] for structurally nowhere dense classes to all monadically stable classes. As a complementary hardness result, we prove that for every hereditary graph class $\mathscr{C}$ that is edge-stable (excludes some half-graph as a semi-induced subgraph) but not monadically stable, first-order model checking is $\mathrm{AW}[*]$-hard on $\mathscr{C}$, and $\mathrm{W}[1]$-hard when restricted to existential sentences. This confirms, in the special case of edge-stable classes, an on-going conjecture that the notion of monadic NIP delimits the tractability of first-order model checking on hereditary classes of graphs. For our tractability result, we first prove that monadically stable graph classes have almost linear neighborhood complexity. Using this, we construct sparse neighborhood covers for monadically stable classes, which provides the missing ingredient for the algorithm of [Dreier, Mählmann, and Siebertz; STOC '23]. The key component of this construction is the usage of orders with low crossing number [Welzl; SoCG '88], a tool from the area of range queries. For our hardness result, we prove a new characterization of monadically stable graph classes in terms of forbidden induced subgraphs. We then use this characterization to show that in hereditary classes that are edge-stable but not monadically stable, one can effectively interpret the class of all graphs using only existential formulas.

Hardness of monadic second-order formulae over succinct graphs

Tree-depth, quantifier elimination, and quantifier rank.

Existential Second-Order Logic Over Graphs: A Complete Complexity-Theoretic Classification

Distributed Model Checking on Graphs of Bounded Treedepth

Ranked Enumeration for MSO on Trees via Knowledge Compilation

Expressiveness of Monadic Second-Order Logics on Infinite Trees of Arbitrary Branching Degree

A syntactic tool for proving hardness in the Second Level of the Polynomial-Time Hierarchy

Slicewise Definability in First-Order Logic with Bounded Quantifier Rank.

First-Order Model Checking on Monadically Stable Graph Classes

Constraint Satisfaction Problems around Skolem Arithmetic

Guarded Second-Order Logic, Spanning Trees, and Network Flows

Compound Logics for Modification Problems

Low-level dichotomy for Quantified Constraint Satisfaction Problems

Quantifying over Trees in Monadic Second-Order Logic

FO-Definability of Shrub-Depth.

Evaluating Restricted First-Order Counting Properties on Nowhere Dense Classes and Beyond

Sum-of-Squares Lower Bounds for the Minimum Circuit Size Problem

Hardness of Robust Graph Isomorphism, Lasserre Gaps, and Asymmetry of Random Graphs

On the Decidability of Monadic Second-Order Logic with Arithmetic Predicates

Graph Expansion, Tseitin Formulas and Resolution Proofs for CSP

Finite Model Theory and Proof Complexity revisited: Distinguishing graphs in Choiceless Polynomial Time and the Extended Polynomial Calculus