Numerical Methods for Detecting Symmetries and Commutant Algebras

Sanjay Moudgalya,Olexei I. Motrunich
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.107.224312
2023-06-02
Abstract:For families of Hamiltonians defined by parts that are local, the most general definition of a symmetry algebra is the commutant algebra, i.e., the algebra of operators that commute with each local part. Thinking about symmetry algebras as commutant algebras allows for the treatment of conventional symmetries and unconventional symmetries (e.g., those responsible for weak ergodicity breaking phenomena) on equal algebraic footing. In this work, we discuss two methods for numerically constructing this commutant algebra starting from a family of Hamiltonians. First, we use the equivalence of this problem to that of simultaneous block-diagonalization of a given set of local operators, and discuss a probabilistic method that has been found to work with probability 1 for both Abelian and non-Abelian symmetries or commutant algebras. Second, we map this problem onto the problem of determining frustration-free ground states of certain Hamiltonians, and we use ideas from tensor network algorithms to efficiently solve this problem in one dimension. These numerical methods are useful in detecting standard and non-standard conserved quantities in families of Hamiltonians, which includes examples of regular symmetries, Hilbert space fragmentation, and quantum many-body scars, and we show many such examples. In addition, they are necessary for verifying several conjectures on the structure of the commutant algebras in these cases, which we have put forward in earlier works. Finally, we also discuss similar methods for the inverse problem of determining local operators with a given symmetry or commutant algebra, which connects to existing methods in the literature. A special case of this construction reduces to well-known ``Eigenstate to Hamiltonian" methods for constructing Hermitian local operators that have a given state as an eigenstate.
Strongly Correlated Electrons,Statistical Mechanics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to address the problem of how to numerically construct the corresponding symmetry algebra (i.e., commutator algebra) from a set of local Hamiltonians. Specifically, the authors propose two methods to achieve this goal: 1. **Simultaneous Block Diagonalization Method**: - Transform the problem into simultaneously block diagonalizing a set of local operators. - Propose a probabilistic method that has a high success rate in dealing with both Abelian and non-Abelian symmetries or commutator algebras. 2. **Lie Method**: - Map the problem to determining the frustration-free ground state problem of certain Hamiltonians. - Utilize the ideas of tensor network algorithms to efficiently solve this problem in one-dimensional systems. These numerical methods not only help detect standard and non-standard conserved quantities but also include phenomena such as conventional symmetries, Hilbert space fragmentation, and quantum many-body scars. Additionally, these methods are necessary for verifying conjectures about the structure of commutator algebras proposed in previous works. ### Background and Motivation The study of symmetries occupies a central position in many areas of physics. For example, understanding symmetries can classify various phases of matter and their transitions, define the Gibbs ensemble that describes the thermodynamics of systems, etc. Therefore, given the Hamiltonian of a quantum system, determining its symmetries is very important and is usually the first step in solving the problem. However, recent research has shown that not all symmetries in natural Hamiltonians are conventional on-site global symmetries. Exploring these unconventional symmetries is crucial for understanding dynamic behaviors such as weak ergodicity breaking. ### Main Contributions 1. **Generalized Definition of Symmetry**: - The authors introduce a framework that provides a non-trivial definition of symmetry and conserved quantities, which naturally covers conventional symmetries in standard Hamiltonians and explains unconventional symmetries such as quantum many-body scars and Hilbert space fragmentation. 2. **Numerical Methods**: - Propose two numerical methods to construct commutator algebras, which are applicable to both Abelian and non-Abelian symmetries. - These methods can be used to detect standard and non-standard conserved quantities, including conventional symmetries, Hilbert space fragmentation, and quantum many-body scars. 3. **Inverse Problem**: - Discuss how to construct local operators from given symmetries or commutator algebras, which is consistent with methods in existing literature. ### Conclusion Through these numerical methods, the authors are able to systematically detect and construct the symmetries and conserved quantities of local Hamiltonians, which is of great significance for understanding the behavior of complex quantum systems.