Consistency of New CDF-II W Boson Mass with 123-Model

B. Ait Ouazghour,R. Benbrik,E. Ghourmin,M. Ouchemhou,L. Rahili
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2023.138009
2023-06-28
Abstract:Following the recent update measurement of the W boson mass performed by the CDF-II experiment at Fermilab which indicates $7\sigma$ deviation from the SM prediction. As a consequence, the open question is whether there are extensions of the SM that can carry such a remarkable deviation or what phenomenological repercussions this has. In this paper, we investigate what the theoretical constraints reveal about the \ott model. Also, we study the consistency of a CDF W boson mass measurement with the 123-model expectations, taking into account theoretical and experimental constraints. Both fit results of $S$ and $T$ parameters before and after $m_{W}^{\rm{CDF}}$ measurement are, moreover, considered in this study. Under these conditions, we found that the 123-model prediction is consistent with the measured $m_{W}^{\rm{CDF}}$ at a $95\%$ Confidence Level (CL).
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is regarding the significant deviation between the recently measured mass of the W boson in the CDF - II experiment and the predicted value in the Standard Model (SM). Specifically, the mass of the W boson reported by the CDF - II experiment is about 7 standard deviations (σ) higher than the Standard Model prediction. This significant deviation has sparked interest in extended theories of the Standard Model, especially those models that can explain this deviation. The paper explores the theoretical constraints of the 123 model under this new measurement and its consistency with the CDF - II measurement results. ### Main research contents: 1. **Background introduction**: - High - precision collider experiments have imposed strict limitations on the Standard Model and its possible extensions. - The mass of the W boson \( m_{W}^{\text{CDF}} = 80.4335 \pm 0.0094 \, \text{GeV} \) measured in the recent CDF - II experiment has a deviation of about 7 standard deviations from the Standard Model prediction \( m_{W}^{\text{SM}} = 80.357 \pm 0.006 \, \text{GeV} \). - This deviation strongly suggests that there may be new physical phenomena, especially models related to spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB), such as models with an extended Higgs sector. 2. **Introduction to the 123 model**: - The 123 model contains three CP - even Higgs bosons \( h_1, h_2, h_3 \), one CP - odd Higgs boson \( A \), a pair of charged Higgs bosons \( H^\pm \), and a pair of doubly - charged Higgs bosons \( H^{\pm\pm} \). - This model can provide stable candidates for dark matter and explain the tiny neutrino mass. 3. **Theoretical and experimental constraints**: - The paper discusses in detail the parameter space of the 123 model and considers the theoretical requirements of unitarity, perturbativity, and vacuum stability. - The consistency with the LHC 95% confidence - level constraints and the property matching of SM - like Higgs bosons are checked using public codes such as HiggsBounds - 5.10.2 and HiggsSignals - 2.6.2. - The consistency between the model and experimental data is evaluated through the slope parameters \( S \) and \( T \) in electroweak precision observables (EWPO). 4. **Results and discussion**: - The paper evaluates the consistency between the mass of the W boson \( m_W \) measured by CDF - II and the prediction of the 123 model by randomly scanning the parameter space of the 123 model. - The results show that, after considering the theoretical and experimental constraints, the prediction of the 123 model is consistent with the mass of the W boson measured by CDF - II at the 95% confidence level. - In particular, the paper finds that the non - zero mass splitting among \( h_2, h_3, A, H^\pm, H^{\pm\pm} \) in the 123 model is a key factor in explaining the CDF - II measurement results. ### Conclusion: Through detailed theoretical analysis and parameter scanning, the paper shows the potential of the 123 model in explaining the anomaly in the mass of the W boson measured by the CDF - II experiment. The research results indicate that the prediction of the 123 model is consistent with the CDF - II measurement results at the 95% confidence level, which provides important clues for further exploration of new physics beyond the Standard Model.