An EFT hunter's guide to two-to-two scattering: HEFT and SMEFT on-shell amplitudes

Hongkai Liu,Teng Ma,Yael Shadmi,Michael Waterbury
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP05%282023%29241
2023-06-02
Abstract:We derive the contact terms contributing to the four-point amplitudes of the standard-model particles, keeping terms with up to quartic energy growth. Imposing just the unbroken low-energy symmetry, and treating the electroweak gauge bosons and the Higgs as independent degrees of freedom, we obtain the most general four-point contact-term amplitudes, corresponding to the HEFT framework. The contact terms are spanned by a basis of Stripped Contact Terms (SCTs), which carry the polarization information, multiplied by polynomials in the Mandelstam invariants. For terms with quadratic energy growth, we also derive the low-energy SMEFT predictions, via on-shell Higgsing of the massless SMEFT contact terms. We discuss several aspects of bottom-up versus top-down on-shell derivations of the HEFT and SMEFT amplitudes, highlighting in particular the simple counting of HEFT dimensions in the on-shell approach and the transparent relation between perturbative unitarity and gauge-invariance in the little-group covariant massive spinor formalism. Our results provide a formulation of EFT analyses directly in terms of observable quantities. For terms with quadratic energy growth, we also provide the mapping to the Warsaw basis.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to accurately describe the four - point contact terms in the two - body scattering processes of Standard Model particles through the method of effective field theory (EFT). Specifically, the paper focuses on deriving four - point contact terms that include Standard Model particles (especially the Higgs boson, electroweak gauge bosons, etc.) under the condition of maintaining low - energy symmetry, and these contact terms can have the characteristic of energy growth up to the fourth order. Through this method, the authors aim to provide a framework that can directly perform effective field theory analysis in the form of observables, especially in the context of Higgs Effective Field Theory (HEFT) and Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT). ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Derivation of HEFT contact terms**: - The paper derives four - point contact terms that include Standard Model particles, and these contact terms can have energy growth up to the fourth order at most. These contact terms are derived without breaking low - energy symmetry, where electroweak gauge bosons and the Higgs boson are regarded as independent degrees of freedom. - The contact terms are composed of Stripped Contact Terms (SCTs), which carry polarization information and are multiplied by polynomials of Mandelstam invariants. 2. **Derivation of SMEFT contact terms**: - For contact terms with quadratic energy growth, the paper also derives the predictions of the low - energy Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT). This is obtained by "Higgsizing" the massless SMEFT contact terms. - The paper discusses the differences between the bottom - up and top - down methods in deriving HEFT and SMEFT contact terms, especially emphasizing the transparent relationship between perturbative single - valuedness and gauge invariance in the small - group covariant heavy - mass spinor form. 3. **Physical significance and applications**: - These results provide a formulation directly based on observables for effective field theory analysis, especially in the high - precision measurement of Standard Model particle interactions, such as the interactions between electroweak gauge bosons and top quarks in LHC experiments. - Through these contact terms, the interactions of Standard Model particles can be systematically parameterized, thereby indirectly searching for new physical phenomena. ### Formula examples - **Representation of SCTs**: \[ \text{SCT}=\langle 12\rangle [12]\quad \text{or}\quad (12)^{2} \] where \(\langle 12\rangle\) and \([12]\) are used to describe the spinor structure respectively. - **Mandelstam invariants**: \[ s=(p_{1}+p_{2})^{2},\quad t=(p_{1}-p_{3})^{2},\quad u=(p_{1}-p_{4})^{2} \] - **Example of four - point contact terms**: \[ M(WWhh)=C_{00}^{WWhh}\langle 12\rangle [12]+C_{\pm\pm}^{WWhh}(12)^{2} \] where \(C_{00}^{WWhh}\) and \(C_{\pm\pm}^{WWhh}\) are independent HEFT coefficients. ### Conclusion Through these derivations, the paper provides a powerful tool for studying the high - precision scattering processes of Standard Model particles, especially in the interactions between the Higgs boson and electroweak gauge bosons. These results not only help to understand the interaction mechanisms within the Standard Model, but also provide new ways to indirectly search for new physical phenomena beyond the Standard Model.