Evaluating approaches for on-the-fly machine learning interatomic potential for activated mechanisms sampling with the activation-relaxation technique nouveau

Eugène Sanscartier,Félix Saint-Denis,Karl-Étienne Bolduc,Normand Mousseau
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0143211
2023-06-22
Abstract:In the last few years, much efforts have gone into developing universal machine-learning potentials able to describe interactions for a wide range of structures and phases. Yet, as attention turns to more complex materials including alloys, disordered and heterogeneous systems, the challenge of providing reliable description for all possible environment become ever more costly. In this work, we evaluate the benefits of using specific versus general potentials for the study of activated mechanisms in solid-state materials. More specifically, we tests three machine-learning fitting approaches using the moment-tensor potential to reproduce a reference potential when exploring the energy landscape around a vacancy in Stillinger-Weber silicon crystal and silicon-germanium zincblende structure using the activation-relaxation technique nouveau (ARTn). We find that a a targeted on-the-fly approach specific and integrated to ARTn generates the highest precision on the energetic and geometry of activated barriers, while remaining cost-effective. This approach expands the type of problems that can be addressed with high-accuracy ML potentials.
Materials Science,Computational Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores different methods of using machine learning potentials in sampling activation mechanisms in solid materials and evaluates the effectiveness and efficiency of these methods. Specifically, the study focuses on assessing the performance of specific versus general machine learning potentials in studying activation mechanisms in solid materials. The core issue of the paper is to address the problem of describing activation mechanisms in complex materials such as alloys, disordered, and heterogeneous systems. As the research subjects shift towards more complex material systems, providing a reliable description of all possible environments becomes increasingly challenging, especially when involving activation processes. Therefore, the main objective of the paper is to evaluate the methods of using specific versus general potentials in the study of activation mechanisms in solid materials and to compare the effects of different machine learning fitting strategies. Specifically, the authors tested three different machine learning fitting methods using Moment-Tensor Potential (MTP) to reproduce reference potentials and explored the energy landscape in Stillinger-Weber silicon crystals and silicon-germanium-zinc silicate structures. These three methods include: 1. Pure Molecular Dynamics Learning (ML-MD). 2. Molecular Dynamics Learning combined with On-the-Fly training during the Activation Relaxation Technique new version (OTF-MDART). 3. On-the-Fly training only during the ARTn process (OTF-ART). The study found that the On-the-Fly training method specialized for the ARTn process could achieve the highest energy barriers and geometric accuracy at a lower cost. This method extends the types of problems that can be addressed using high-accuracy machine learning potentials. In summary, the paper aims to address how to effectively utilize machine learning potentials to simulate activation mechanisms in solid materials and experimentally verifies the effectiveness and practicality of specific machine learning potentials.