Developing a Framework for Heterotopias as Discursive Playgrounds: A Comparative Analysis of Non-Immersive and Immersive Technologies

Elif Hilal Korkut,Elif Surer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.08565

2023-01-20

Abstract:The discursive space represents the reordering of knowledge gained through accumulation. In the digital age, multimedia has become the language of information, and the space for archival practices is provided by non-immersive technologies, resulting in the disappearance of several layers from discursive activities. Heterotopias are unique, multilayered epistemic contexts that connect other systems through the exchange of information. This paper describes a process to create a framework for Virtual Reality, Mixed Reality, and personal computer environments based on heterotopias to provide absent layers. This study provides virtual museum space as an informational terrain that contains a "world within worlds" and presents place production as a layer of heterotopia and the subject of discourse. Automation for the individual multimedia content is provided via various sorting and grouping algorithms, and procedural content generation algorithms such as Binary Space Partitioning, Cellular Automata, Growth Algorithm, and Procedural Room Generation. Versions of the framework were comparatively evaluated through a user study involving 30 participants, considering factors such as usability, technology acceptance, and presence. The results of the study show that the framework can serve diverse contexts to construct multilayered digital habitats and is flexible for integration into professional and daily life practices.

Human-Computer Interaction,Multimedia

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in the digital age, as multimedia becomes the language of information, the archival practice space provided by non - immersive technologies has led to the disappearance of several discursive levels. The authors propose a framework based on the concept of Heterotopias, aiming to restore these missing levels through virtual reality (VR), mixed reality (MR) and personal computer environments. Specifically, the paper explores how to use immersive technologies to create a multi - layer digital habitat to support "archival practice" in personal and professional fields. In addition, the paper also compares the effects of different technology platforms (PC, VR, MR) in terms of usability, technology acceptance and presence through user research to evaluate the effectiveness and applicability of the developed framework.

The main objectives of the paper include:
1. **Constructing the framework**: Develop a framework that can support users to create their own digital habitats through immersive technologies, especially in combination with the ability of personal archives.
2. **Comparing technology platforms**: Through user research, compare the differences in user experience among the three technology platforms of PC, VR and MR, especially in terms of usability, technology acceptance and presence.
3. **Exploring design features**: Identify which design features can increase the integration of immersive technologies in different scenarios, thereby improving the overall performance of the system and user experience.

Through these objectives, the paper aims to provide a flexible and multi - functional tool to help users carry out knowledge production and communication in a multi - layer digital environment, while exploring the impact of different technology platforms on user experience.