Differential current noise as an identifier of Andreev bound states that induce nearly quantized conductance plateaus

Zhan Cao,Gu Zhang,Hao Zhang,Ying-Xin Liang,Wan-Xiu He,Ke He,Dong E. Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.108.L121407
2023-09-15
Abstract:Quantized conductance plateaus, a celebrated hallmark of Majorana bound states (MBSs) predicted a decade ago, have recently been observed with small deviations in iron-based superconductors and hybrid nanowires. Here, we demonstrate that nearly quantized conductance plateaus can also arise from trivial Andreev bound states (ABSs). To avoid ABS interruptions, we propose identifying ABS-induced quantized conductance plateaus by measuring the associated differential current noise $P$ versus bias voltage $V$. Specifically, for a quantized conductance plateau induced by one or multiple low-energy ABSs, the associated $P(V)$ curve exhibits a double-peak around zero bias, with the peak positions at $e|V|\approx 3k_B T$ (where $T$ is the temperature) and peak values larger than $2e^3/h$. These features greatly contrast those of an MBS or quasi-MBS, whose $P(V)$ curve displays a broad zero-bias dip and is consistently below $2e^3/h$. This protocol can be practically implemented in a variety of MBS candidate platforms using an electrode or STM tip as a probe.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to distinguish the approximately quantized conductance platforms caused by topologically non - trivial Majorana bound states (MBSs) and those caused by topologically trivial Andreev bound states (ABSs). Specifically, the paper proposes a method to identify their sources by measuring the differential current noise \(P(V)\) associated with these conductance platforms. ### Background Problem In recent years, nearly quantized conductance platforms have been observed in iron - based superconductors and hybrid nanowires, and these platforms are considered to be caused by Majorana bound states (MBSs). However, these observations are controversial because ordinary Andreev bound states (ABSs) may also lead to similar conductance characteristics. Therefore, how to accurately distinguish these two types of bound states has become a key issue. ### Core Contributions of the Paper 1. **ABSs Can Cause Approximately Quantized Conductance Platforms**: The paper shows that zero - energy or low - energy Andreev bound states (ABSs) can also produce nearly quantized conductance platforms in a large parameter space, and this phenomenon becomes more significant as the temperature rises. 2. **Distinguishing by Differential Current Noise**: In order to distinguish the conductance platforms caused by MBSs and ABSs, the paper proposes a method based on the differential current noise \(P(V)\). Specifically: - For the conductance platforms caused by MBSs or quasi - MBSs (QMBSs), the \(P(V)\) curve has a wide dip at zero bias voltage, and the maximum value is less than \(2e^3/h\). - For the conductance platforms caused by ABSs, the \(P(V)\) curve will show a double - peak near zero bias voltage, the peak position is at \(e|V|\approx3k_BT\), and the peak value is greater than \(2e^3/h\). 3. **Experimental Feasibility**: Since the tunneling conductance and the differential current noise can be accurately measured by the same probe, this method can be practically applied on various MBS candidate platforms. ### Formula Summary - The formula for zero - bias conductance \(G(0)\) is: \[ G(0) = \begin{cases} \frac{2e^2}{h} & \text{for } r = 0 \\ \frac{4e^2\sin^2\theta}{h} & \text{for } r>0 \end{cases} \] - The formula for differential current noise \(P(V)\) is: \[ P(V)=\left|\frac{dS(V)}{dV}\right| \] where \(S(V)\) is the current noise, and its calculation formula is as follows: \[ S(V)=\text{sgn}(V)\frac{8e^2}{h}\sum_{s = \pm}\int_0^{eV}d\epsilon T_s(\epsilon)[1 - T_s(\epsilon)] \] Through these methods, researchers can more reliably evaluate whether the material system has reached the quality standard of excluding trivial zero - energy ABSs, thereby providing support for further confirming the existence of Majorana bound states.