Bike Frames: Understanding the Implicit Portrayal of Cyclists in the News

Xingmeng Zhao,Dan Schumacher,Sashank Nalluri,Xavier Walton,Suhana Shrestha,Anthony Rios
2024-07-17
Abstract:Increasing cycling for transportation or recreation can boost health and reduce the environmental impacts of vehicles. However, news agencies' ideologies and reporting styles often influence public perception of cycling. For example, if news agencies overly report cycling accidents, it may make people perceive cyclists as "dangerous," reducing the number of cyclists who opt to cycle. Additionally, a decline in cycling can result in less government funding for safe infrastructure. In this paper, we develop a method for detecting the perceived perception of cyclists within news headlines. We introduce a new dataset called ``Bike Frames'' to accomplish this. The dataset consists of 31,480 news headlines and 1,500 annotations. Our focus is on analyzing 11,385 headlines from the United States. We also introduce the BikeFrame Chain-of-Code framework to predict cyclist perception, identify accident-related headlines, and determine fault. This framework uses pseudocode for precise logic and integrates news agency bias analysis for improved predictions over traditional chain-of-thought reasoning in large language models. Our method substantially outperforms other methods, and most importantly, we find that incorporating news bias information substantially impacts performance, improving the average F1 from .739 to .815. Finally, we perform a comprehensive case study on US-based news headlines, finding reporting differences between news agencies and cycling-specific websites as well as differences in reporting depending on the gender of cyclists. WARNING: This paper contains descriptions of accidents and death.
Computers and Society,Computation and Language
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address how stereotypes and negative portrayals of cyclists in news reports affect public perception of cycling, which in turn influences cycling behavior and government investment in cycling infrastructure. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Public Perception**: The over-reporting of cycling accidents by news media may lead the public to perceive cycling as a dangerous activity, thereby reducing the number of people choosing to cycle. 2. **Government Investment**: If the number of people choosing to cycle decreases, it may lead to a reduction in government investment in safe cycling infrastructure. 3. **Gender Differences**: The study also explores whether there are differences in the portrayal of cyclists of different genders in news reports and how these differences affect public perception of cyclists. To investigate these issues, the authors developed a method to detect perceptions of cyclists in news headlines and introduced a new dataset called "Bike Frames." This dataset contains 31,480 news headlines and 1,500 annotations, with a focus on analyzing 11,385 U.S. news headlines. Additionally, the authors proposed a framework called BikeFrame Chain-of-Code (CoC) to predict perceptions of cyclists, identify accident-related headlines, and determine responsibility. This framework uses pseudocode for precise logical management and combines news agency bias analysis to improve prediction performance.