Occupant-Oriented Demand Response with Multi-Zone Thermal Building Control

Moritz Frahm,Thomas Dengiz,Philipp Zwickel,Heiko Maaß,Jörg Matthes,Veit Hagenmeyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2023.121454

2023-06-12

Abstract:In future energy systems with high shares of renewable energy sources, the electricity demand of buildings has to react to the fluctuating electricity generation in view of stability. As buildings consume one-third of global energy and almost half of this energy accounts for Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) systems, HVAC are suitable for shifting their electricity consumption in time. To this end, intelligent control strategies are necessary as the conventional control of HVAC is not optimized for the actual demand of occupants and the current situation in the electricity grid. In this paper, we present the novel multi-zone controller Price Storage Control (PSC) that not only considers room-individual Occupants' Thermal Satisfaction (OTS), but also the available energy storage, and energy prices. The main feature of PSC is that it does not need a building model or forecasts of future demands to derive the control actions for multiple rooms in a building. For comparison, we use an ideal, error-free Model Predictive Control (MPC), a simplified variant without storage consideration (PC), and a conventional hysteresis-based two-point control. We evaluate the four controllers in a multi-zone environment for heating a building in winter and consider two different scenarios that differ in how much the permitted temperatures vary. In addition, we compare the impact of model parameters with high and low thermal capacitance. The results show that PSC strongly outperforms the conventional control approach in both scenarios and for both parameters. For high capacitance, it leads to 22 % costs reduction while the ideal MPC achieves cost reductions of more than 39 %. Considering that PSC does not need any building model or forecast, as opposed to MPC, the results support the suitability of our developed control strategy for controlling HVAC systems in future energy systems.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the building's electricity demand responds to the fluctuating power supply to maintain grid stability in future power systems with a high proportion of renewable energy. Specifically, the paper focuses on achieving the electricity demand response of building heating systems through multi - zone thermal control strategies. Buildings consume about one - third of the world's final energy, and nearly half of it is used for heating, ventilation and air - conditioning (HVAC) systems. In order to reduce emissions and improve the utilization rate of renewable energy, it is necessary to develop intelligent control strategies that can optimize the operation of HVAC systems according to the actual occupant needs and the current grid situation.

The paper proposes a new multi - zone controller - Price - Storage - Control (PSC), which takes into account not only the Occupant Thermal Comfort (OTS) of each room, but also the available energy storage and energy prices. The main feature of PSC is that it can formulate control actions for multiple rooms in a building without the need for a building model or future load prediction. Compared with traditional control methods, PSC performs well in reducing electricity costs and improving occupant thermal comfort. In particular, in the case of high heat capacity, it can achieve a cost savings of 22%, while the ideal Model Predictive Control (MPC) can achieve a cost savings of more than 39%. Considering that PSC does not require any building model or prediction, this supports its applicability as a control for HVAC systems in future energy systems.