A lot of fudge around A + B = C

Benne de Weger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.03050

2023-01-08

Abstract:This paper reports on experiments searching for elliptic curves over Q with large Tamagawa products. The main idea is to look among curves related to good abc-triples.

Number Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to find elliptic curves with large Tamagawa product ($\tau$) and high Tamagawa quality ($q_{\tau}$). Specifically, the author hopes to experimentally verify the following points:

1. **Finding elliptic curves with large Tamagawa product**: The author hopes to find some special elliptic curves whose Tamagawa product $\tau$ is unusually large.
2. **Finding elliptic curves with high Tamagawa quality**: The author defines the Tamagawa quality $q_{\tau}$ as:
\[
q_{\tau}=\frac{\log \tau}{\log N}\cdot\frac{\log\log N}{\log N}
\]
where $N$ is the conductor of the elliptic curve, and $\tau$ is the Tamagawa product. The author hopes to find elliptic curves with high $q_{\tau}$.

### Main Motivations

The author's research motivations come from the following aspects:

- **Birch and Swinnerton - Dyer Conjecture**: This conjecture implies that when the Tamagawa product $\tau$ is small, there may be a large Tate - Shafarevich group (Sha). Therefore, studying elliptic curves with large $\tau$ helps to understand this conjecture.
- **abc Conjecture and Its Improvements**: Hector Pasten's conjecture about the Tamagawa product states that:
\[
\tau\ll N^{\left(\frac{7}{3}\log 3+\epsilon\right)/\log\log N}
\]
The author hopes to experimentally verify this conjecture and explore whether there are higher bounds.

### Research Methods

In order to find elliptic curves with large $\tau$ and high $q_{\tau}$, the author adopts the following methods:

1. **Screening from databases**: Use the data in the Cremona database and the LMFDB database for screening to find elliptic curves with high $q_{\tau}$.
2. **Constructing Frey - Hellegouarch curves using abc - triple**: Construct Frey - Hellegouarch curves through known high - quality abc - triple and calculate their Tamagawa product and quality.
3. **Quadratic twists and isogenous curves**: Perform quadratic twists and isogenous transformations on Frey - Hellegouarch curves to further explore possible curves with large $\tau$ and high $q_{\tau}$.

### Experimental Results

The author has found some elliptic curves with large $\tau$ and high $q_{\tau}$ through the above methods. For example:

- The largest $\tau$ is $152202903552$, and the corresponding $q_{\tau} = 2.18988$.
- The highest $q_{\tau}$ is $2.39875$, and the corresponding $\tau = 39813120$.

These results show that Frey - Hellegouarch curves are indeed an effective way to find elliptic curves with high Tamagawa quality.

### Conclusions and Prospects

The author concludes that although it is relatively easy to find elliptic curves with large $\tau$, it is more challenging to find elliptic curves with high $q_{\tau}$. In addition, the author questions Pasten's conjecture and suggests that future research can further explore the lower bound problem of $\limsup_{E/\mathbb{Q}}q_{\tau}$.