Charles Babbage, Ada Lovelace, and the Bernoulli Numbers

Thomas J. Misa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/2809523.2809527

2023-01-08

Abstract:This chapter makes needed corrections to an unduly negative scholarly view of Ada Lovelace. Credit between Lovelace and Babbage is not a zero-sum game, where any credit added to Lovelace somehow detracts from Babbage. Ample evidence indicates Babbage and Lovelace each had important contributions to the famous 1843 Sketch of Babbage's Analytical Engine and the accompanying Notes. Further, Lovelace's correspondence with two highly accomplished figures in 19th century mathematics, Charles Babbage and Augustus De Morgan, establish her mathematical background and sophistication. Babbage and Lovelace's treatment of the Bernoulli numbers in Note 'G' spotlights this aspect of their collaboration. Finally, while acknowledging significant definitional problems in calling Lovelace the world's "first computer programmer," I affirm that Lovelace created an elemental sequence of instructions -- that is, an algorithm -- for computing the series of Bernoulli numbers.

Computers and Society,History and Overview,General Literature

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are mainly about the controversial issues regarding the evaluation of Ada Lovelace's contributions in the history of computer science development. Specifically:

1. **Correcting negative academic views of Ada Lovelace**: The paper points out that the existing academic literature often has a negative attitude towards Ada Lovelace's contributions, believing that her mathematical background is insufficient and that her contributions in "Sketch" and its annotations are overestimated. By re - examining relevant historical materials, especially the correspondence between Lovelace, Babbage and Augustus De Morgan, the author puts forward several suggestions to correct these negative views.

2. **Emphasizing the cooperative relationship between Lovelace and Babbage**: The author believes that the cooperation between Lovelace and Babbage should not be regarded as a zero - sum game, that is, increasing the praise for Lovelace will not reduce the recognition of Babbage. On the contrary, both of them made important contributions in "Sketch" and its annotations in 1843.

3. **Lovelace's mathematical ability**: By analyzing the detailed correspondence between Lovelace and De Morgan, the paper proves that she has a solid mathematical foundation and has carried out in - depth study and research in mathematics. This refutes the previous doubts about her mathematical ability.

4. **Lovelace's contributions in algorithm design**: Pay special attention to Lovelace's handling of Bernoulli numbers in Note G. The paper points out that although the underlying mathematics may be Babbage's work, Lovelace did design a detailed algorithm to calculate the Bernoulli number sequence, which was for Babbage's Analytical Engine. This algorithm demonstrates Lovelace's mathematical and programming abilities.

5. **Defining "the first computer programmer"**: The paper discusses the definition problem of calling Lovelace "the first computer programmer in the world". Although there are some disputes, the evidence shows that Lovelace did create a step - by - step instruction sequence, that is, an algorithm, for calculating the Bernoulli number sequence, which conforms to the basic concept of modern computer programs.

In short, this paper aims to correct the negative views of Ada Lovelace's contributions by re - evaluating historical materials and emphasize her important role in the early development of computer science.