Abstract:It is difficult to construct a post-inflation QCD axion model that solves the axion quality problem (and hence the Strong CP problem) without introducing a cosmological disaster. In a post-inflation axion model, the axion field value is randomized during the Peccei-Quinn phase transition, and axion domain walls form at the QCD phase transition. We emphasize that the gauge equivalence of all minima of the axion potential (i.e., domain wall number one) is insufficient to solve the cosmological domain wall problem. The axion string on which a domain wall ends must exist as an individual object (as opposed to a multi-string state), and it must be produced in the early universe. These conditions are often not satisfied in concrete models. Post-inflation axion models also face a potential problem from fractionally charged relics; solving this problem often leads to low-energy Landau poles for Standard Model gauge couplings, reintroducing the quality problem. We study several examples, finding that models that solve the quality problem face cosmological problems, and vice versa. This is not a no-go theorem; nonetheless, we argue that it is much more difficult than generally appreciated to find a viable post-inflation QCD axion model. Successful examples may have a nonstandard cosmological history (e.g., multiple types of cosmic axion strings of different tensions), undermining the widespread expectation that the post-inflation QCD axion scenario predicts a unique mass for axion dark matter.

High-quality axions in a class of chiral $U(1)$ gauge theories

High-Quality Axions in a Class of Chiral U(1) Gauge Theories

High-Quality Axions from Higher-Form Symmetries in Extra Dimensions

High Quality QCD Axion via Electric-Magnetic Duality

Axion quality from the (anti)symmetric of SU($$ \mathcal{N} $$)

High Quality Axion in Supersymmetric Models

Model of the quintessence axion

Gravitational instantons and the quality problem of the QCD axion: Facts, speculations, and statements in between

The Quality/Cosmology Tension for a Post-Inflation QCD Axion

Quantization of Axion-Gauge Couplings and Non-Invertible Higher Symmetries

Implications of Protecting the QCD Axion in the Dual Description

Quantization of Axion-Gauge Couplings and Noninvertible Higher Symmetries

Extra-Dimensional Axion Expectations

Hadrophobic Axion from GUT

Dark Matter as Ultralight Axion-Like particle in $E_6 \times U(1)_X$ GUT with QCD Axion

From axion quality and naturalness problems to a high-quality $\mathbb{Z}_{N}$ QCD relaxion

The Cosmological Dynamics of String Theory Axion Strings

Hybrid SO(10) Axion Model Without Quality Problem

Stabilizing the axion by discrete gauge symmetries

Hadrophobic axion from a GUT