C. Leloup,L. Heitz,J. Neveu
Abstract:The DBI-Galileon model is a scalar-tensor theory of gravity which is defined as the most general theory of the dynamics of a 4D brane embedded in a 5D bulk. It is of particular interest as it introduces only a few free parameters, all with a clear physical meaning, such as the brane tension which is related to the cosmological constant. From the tight constraints on the gravitational waves speed, we are naturally led to consider the non-relativistic limit of the model where the kinetic energy of the brane is small compared to its tension, that we study in the context of late-time cosmology. We show that the DBI-Galileon in the non-relativistic limit is an expansion around General Relativity (GR) which can be expressed as a shift-symmetric Horndeski theory. We develop the description of this theory at the background and perturbation level. However, by studying the scalar and tensor perturbations around a flat FLRW background, we find that they contain a ghost degree of freedom leading to a fatal instability of the vacuum for every combination of the free parameters. In order to avoid it in the more general cases of shift-symmetric Horndeski theories, we emphasize which of the Horndeski terms are in competition to produce this instability.
High Energy Physics - Theory,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the stability problem of the DBI - Galileon model in the cosmological context under the non - relativistic limit. Specifically, the paper explores the stability of scalar and tensor perturbations of the DBI - Galileon model in the late - time cosmological context (i.e., the flat FLRW background). The author finds that in this case, there is a ghost - degree - of - freedom in the model, which leads to a fatal instability in the vacuum state. To further understand this problem, the paper also discusses how to avoid this instability in the more general shift - symmetric Horndeski theory.
### Main problems
1. **DBI - Galileon model under the non - relativistic limit**:
- The paper first describes the DBI - Galileon model under the non - relativistic limit, that is, when the kinetic energy of the brane is much smaller than its tension.
- In this limit, the DBI - Galileon model can be regarded as an extension of general relativity (GR) and can be expressed in terms of the shift - symmetric Horndeski theory.
2. **Cosmological background evolution**:
- The paper derives the Friedmann equations in the flat FLRW background and studies the evolution of the background cosmology.
- Through these equations, the author finds that the DBI - Galileon model is very close to the standard ΛCDM model at the background level, but has different interpretations of physical parameters.
3. **Stability conditions**:
- The paper analyzes in detail the stability conditions of scalar and tensor perturbations.
- The author finds that under the non - relativistic limit, tensor perturbations are stable, but there is a ghost - degree - of - freedom in scalar perturbations, causing the model to exhibit fatal instability under any combination of parameters.
### Key formulas
- **Tensor stability conditions**:
\[
Q_t \simeq \frac{1}{4} \left(1 + 2 (\bar{H} \tilde{x})^2 \right) > 0, \quad c_t^2 \simeq 1 - (\bar{H} \tilde{x})^2 \geq 0
\]
- **Scalar stability conditions**:
\[
Q_s \simeq \frac{3}{2} (\Omega_0^\Lambda - \bar{H}^2) \tilde{x}^2 > 0, \quad c_s^2 \simeq 1 + \frac{2 (\eta \bar{H}^2 \tilde{x}' - \bar{H} \bar{H}' - 2 \xi \bar{H}^4 \tilde{x}')}{3 (\Omega_0^\Lambda - \bar{H}^2)} \geq 0
\]
### Conclusion
The main conclusion of the paper is that under the non - relativistic limit, there is a ghost - degree - of - freedom in the scalar perturbations of the DBI - Galileon model in the flat FLRW background, which leads to the instability of the model's vacuum state. To avoid this instability, higher - order relativistic dynamics need to be considered or other mechanisms need to be introduced. In addition, the paper also provides the general form of the stability conditions of the shift - symmetric Horndeski theory under the non - relativistic limit, providing a theoretical basis for further research.