Abstract:The principle of holography of information states that in massless gravity, it is possible to extract bulk information using asymptotic boundary operators. In our work, we study this principle in a linearized setting about empty flat space and formulate it using Dirac brackets between boundary Hamiltonian and bulk operators. We then address whether the storage of bulk information in flat space linearized massive gravity resembles that of massless gravity. For linearized massless gravity, using Dirac brackets, we recover the necessary criteria for the holography of information. In contrast, we show that the Dirac bracket of the relevant boundary observable with bulk operators vanishes for massive gravity. We use this important distinction to outline the canonical Hilbert space. This leads to split states, and consequently, one cannot use asymptotic boundary observables to extract bulk information in massive gravity. We also argue the split property directly without an explicit reference to the Hilbert space. The result reflects that we can construct local bulk operators in massive gravity, which are obscured from boundary observables due to the lack of diffeomorphism invariance. Our analysis sheds some light on evaporating black holes in the context of the islands proposal.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether in the linearized flat space, massive gravity can extract bulk information through boundary operators like massless gravity. Specifically, the researchers explored whether in massive gravity, boundary observers can fully determine the bulk state using boundary operators, which is achieved in the form of Dirac brackets.
### Background and Motivation of the Paper
1. **Holographic Information Principle**: In massless gravity, bulk information can be extracted through asymptotic boundary operators. This principle is an important feature in massless gravity and depends on the Gauss constraint.
2. **Dirac Bracket Formalism**: Since the gravitational theory is a constrained system, it is very natural to use the Dirac bracket formalism to understand these constraints.
3. **Massive Gravity**: Fierz - Pauli massive gravity is an interesting modification of the gravitational theory and has attracted wide attention in recent years. Researchers hope to understand the role of this theory in the islands proposal during the black hole evaporation process.
### Research Objectives
1. **Verify Known Situations**: Verify the holographic information principle and the split property in linearized massless gravity and electrodynamics through the Dirac bracket formalism.
2. **Explore Massive Gravity**: Determine whether there is a similar holographic information principle at the linearized level in massive gravity.
### Main Results
1. **Massless Gravity**:
- Through Dirac bracket calculations, the holographic information principle in massless gravity was verified.
- The split property does not hold in massless gravity, that is, the bulk state cannot be fully determined by boundary operators.
2. **Massive Gravity**:
- The Dirac matrix in massive gravity was calculated, and it was found that the Dirac bracket between the boundary operator and the bulk operator is zero.
- This means that in massive gravity, boundary observers cannot extract bulk information through boundary operators.
- Further analysis shows that there are split states in massive gravity, so the bulk state cannot be fully determined by boundary operators.
### Specific Calculations
1. **Massless Gravity**:
- Construct the boundary Hamiltonian \(H_{\partial}\) through the Gauss constraint.
- Calculate the Dirac bracket between \(H_{\partial}\) and the bulk operator \(O(z)\), and the result is equal to the Poisson bracket between \(O(z)\) and the matter Hamiltonian.
2. **Massive Gravity**:
- Construct the boundary Hamiltonian \(H_{\partial}\) through the Gauss constraint of massive gravity.
- Calculate the Dirac bracket between \(H_{\partial}\) and the bulk operator \(O(z)\), and the result is zero, indicating that the boundary operator cannot extract bulk information.
### Conclusion
Through detailed Dirac bracket calculations, the paper proves that in massive gravity, boundary observers cannot extract bulk information through boundary operators. This result is of great significance for understanding the information paradox in the black hole evaporation process, especially the content related to the islands proposal.