Can We Rely on Available Models to Identify Candidates for Extended Pelvic Lymph Node Dissection (eplnd) in Men Staged with PSMA-PET? External Validation of the Briganti Nomograms and Development of a Novel Tool to Identify Optimal Candidates for Eplnd
Giorgio Gandaglia,Daniele Robesti,Eugenio Brunocilla,Fabrizio Dal Moro,Jesus Moreno-Sierra,Agostino Mattei,Luca Afferi,Shahrok Shariat,Christopher Darr,Wolfgang Fendler,Giancarlo Marra,Paolo Gontero,Junlong Zhuang,Hongqian Guo,Riccardo Schiavina,Lorenzo Bianchi,Fabio Zattoni,Pawel Rajwa,Juan Gomez-Rivas,Claudia Kesch,Francesco Porpiglia,Daniele Amparore,Maria Picchio,Francesco Montorsi,Alberto Briganti
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0302-2838(23)00699-1
IF: 7.6
2023-01-01
The Journal of Urology
Abstract:You have accessJournal of UrologyCME1 Apr 2023PD10-07 CAN WE RELY ON AVAILABLE MODELS TO IDENTIFY CANDIDATES FOR EXTENDED PELVIC LYMPH NODE DISSECTION (EPLND) IN MEN STAGED WITH PSMA-PET? EXTERNAL VALIDATION OF THE BRIGANTI NOMOGRAMS AND DEVELOPMENT OF A NOVEL TOOL TO IDENTIFY OPTIMAL CANDIDATES FOR EPLND Giorgio Gandaglia, Daniele Robesti, Eugenio Brunocilla, Fabrizio Dal Moro, Jesus Moreno-Sierra, Agostino Mattei, Luca Afferi, Shahrok Shariat, Christopher Darr, Wolfgang Fendler, Giancarlo Marra, Paolo Gontero, Junlong Zhuang, Hongqian Guo, Riccardo Schiavina, Lorenzo Bianchi, Fabio Zattoni, Pawel Rajwa, Juan Gomez-Rivas, Claudia Kesch, Francesco Porpiglia, Daniele Amparore, Maria Picchio, Francesco Montorsi, and Alberto Briganti Giorgio GandagliaGiorgio Gandaglia More articles by this author , Daniele RobestiDaniele Robesti More articles by this author , Eugenio BrunocillaEugenio Brunocilla More articles by this author , Fabrizio Dal MoroFabrizio Dal Moro More articles by this author , Jesus Moreno-SierraJesus Moreno-Sierra More articles by this author , Agostino MatteiAgostino Mattei More articles by this author , Luca AfferiLuca Afferi More articles by this author , Shahrok ShariatShahrok Shariat More articles by this author , Christopher DarrChristopher Darr More articles by this author , Wolfgang FendlerWolfgang Fendler More articles by this author , Giancarlo MarraGiancarlo Marra More articles by this author , Paolo GonteroPaolo Gontero More articles by this author , Junlong ZhuangJunlong Zhuang More articles by this author , Hongqian GuoHongqian Guo More articles by this author , Riccardo SchiavinaRiccardo Schiavina More articles by this author , Lorenzo BianchiLorenzo Bianchi More articles by this author , Fabio ZattoniFabio Zattoni More articles by this author , Pawel RajwaPawel Rajwa More articles by this author , Juan Gomez-RivasJuan Gomez-Rivas More articles by this author , Claudia KeschClaudia Kesch More articles by this author , Francesco PorpigliaFrancesco Porpiglia More articles by this author , Daniele AmparoreDaniele Amparore More articles by this author , Maria PicchioMaria Picchio More articles by this author , Francesco MontorsiFrancesco Montorsi More articles by this author , and Alberto BrigantiAlberto Briganti More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1097/JU.0000000000003250.07AboutPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookLinked InTwitterEmail Abstract INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVE: Nomograms to identify prostate cancer (PCa) patients candidate for extended pelvic lymph node dissection (ePLND) during radical prostatectomy (RP) do not account for PSMA-PET. We hypothesized that available tools may be suboptimal and be recalibrated in cN0 disease at PSMA-PET due to its high negative predictive value (NPV) for lymph node invasion (LNI). METHODS: 662 PCa patients who received a PSMA-PET and subsequent RP + ePLND at 9 referral centres between 2016-2022 were identified. All patients received ePLND regardless of PSMA-PET. Information on preoperative MRI, biopsies and pathologic data were available for all patients. Calibration and discrimination of available nomograms predicting LNI (Briganti 2012, Briganti 2017 and Briganti 2019) was assessed at external validation. The same process was repeated in men with cN0M0 disease at PSMA-PET. The Briganti 2019 model was recalibrated using the multivariable logistic regression coefficients of the variables included in the nomogram in men with cN0M0 disease at PSMA-PET. Calibration plots, the ROC-derived AUC, and decision-curve analyses were used to determine calibration, discrimination, and net benefit associated with the recalibrated nomogram and compare it with available tools. RESULTS: Overall, 115 (17.4%) patients had positive pelvic spots at PSMA PET/CT. LNI rate was 19.5%. The discrimination of the Briganti 2012, 2017, and 2019 nomograms was 75, 75, and 71%. In patients with negative PSMA-PET (n= 537, LNI rate: 10%), the discrimination of the Briganti 2012, 2017, and 2019 nomograms was even lower (72, 72, and 70%). In these patients, the maximum index lesion diameter, seminal vesicle invasion at MRI, and a target biopsy ISUP group 4-5 were associated with a risk of LNI (all p<0.05). A nomogram based on the coefficients of this multivariable regression had a discrimination of 80%, superior calibration characteristics and higher net-benefit compared to other models. A 7% cut-off in the recalibrated nomogram in cN0M0 disease at PSMA-PET would have spared 55% ePLNDs (vs. 29% for the Briganti 2019 nomogram), missing only 3.4% (vs. 2.9%) of LNIs. CONCLUSIONS: Due to its elevated NPV, in men staged with PSMA-PET the Briganti nomogram results in a high number of unnecessary ePLNDs. A novel recalibrated version of the nomogram should be used to identify candidates for ePLND, reducing unnecessary procedures, without missing additional LNIs in men with cN0M0 PCa at PSMA-PET. Source of Funding: NA © 2023 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 209Issue Supplement 4April 2023Page: e328 Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 2023 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.MetricsAuthor Information Giorgio Gandaglia More articles by this author Daniele Robesti More articles by this author Eugenio Brunocilla More articles by this author Fabrizio Dal Moro More articles by this author Jesus Moreno-Sierra More articles by this author Agostino Mattei More articles by this author Luca Afferi More articles by this author Shahrok Shariat More articles by this author Christopher Darr More articles by this author Wolfgang Fendler More articles by this author Giancarlo Marra More articles by this author Paolo Gontero More articles by this author Junlong Zhuang More articles by this author Hongqian Guo More articles by this author Riccardo Schiavina More articles by this author Lorenzo Bianchi More articles by this author Fabio Zattoni More articles by this author Pawel Rajwa More articles by this author Juan Gomez-Rivas More articles by this author Claudia Kesch More articles by this author Francesco Porpiglia More articles by this author Daniele Amparore More articles by this author Maria Picchio More articles by this author Francesco Montorsi More articles by this author Alberto Briganti More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement PDF downloadLoading ...