Innominate science, the specialty of general practice.

C. Harris

1970-10-01

Abstract:S PECIALTIES grow by an internal logic. The logic develops with the acquisition of knowledge and the application of ideas, concentrated within boundaries; the boun-aries change their shape as the pressures within them force them to do so. If general practice grows only by accepting knowledge and ideas from others, and changes its shape only as social, political and economic pressures from without dictate, it cannot hope to claim the status of an academic discipline. At best it can claim a specialized function-that of protecting the true specialties by mustering a unique range of limited abilities to check the onslaught of the public. Reading across the line, A covers the phenomena linking physical stresses to their physical consequences, e.g. bacterial infection or traumatic pain. B and C point to the social and cultural effects of physical illness, e.g. disability, such as blindness, affecting social r6les. E, F, H, and I pertain to the relationships of social and cultural forces, e.g. social changes, such as inventions becoming sources of hazard (road accidents, occupational diseases), and cultural changes such as the breakdown of organized religion or population shifts from country to town. D and G show the effects of culture and society on the physical health of the individual. Epidemi- ologists have studied the effects of poverty, poor housing and social class, for example, upon health; but though these are clear for populations, they are not always easy to prove at the individual level. For each person the important factor will be his own perceptions of the social or cultural variables.