Assessment of URANS and LES Methods in Predicting Wake Shed Behind a Vertical Axis Wind Turbine

Armin Sheidani,Sajad Salavatidezfouli,Giovanni Stabile,Gianluigi Rozza

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jweia.2022.105285

2022-12-26

Abstract:In order to shed light on the Vertical-Axis Wind Turbines (VAWT) wake characteristics, in this paper we present high-fidelity CFD simulations of the flow around an exemplary H-shaped VAWT turbine, and we propose to apply Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) to the computed flow field in the near wake of the rotor. The turbine under consideration was widely studied in previous experimental and computational investigations. In the first part of the study, multiple Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) simulations were performed at the Tip Speed Ratio (TSR) of peak power coefficient, to select the most accurate turbulence model with respect to available data. In the following step, further RANS numerical simulations were performed at different TSRs to compare the power coefficient against experimental data. Then, Large Eddy Simulation (LES) was applied for multiple TSR conditions. The spatial and temporal POD modes along with modal energy for the RANS and LES results were extracted, and the performance of the turbulence models was assessed. Also, an interpretation of the POD modes with respect to the flow structures was given to highlight the most significant time and length scales of the predictions considering the different dynamical levels of approximations of the computational models.

Numerical Analysis

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the accuracy and applicability of different computational methods (URANS and LES) in predicting the wake characteristics of vertical - axis wind turbines (VAWTs). Specifically, the main research questions include:

1. **Evaluating the accuracy of different turbulence models**: By comparing with experimental data, select the most accurate turbulence model to simulate the wake characteristics of VAWTs.
2. **Comparing the performance of RANS and LES methods**: Explore the performance of the two methods at different tip - speed ratios (TSRs), especially their ability to capture the time and length - scale structures in the wake region.
3. **Applying POD analysis**: Use the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) method to decompose the calculated flow fields, in order to reveal the hidden flow structures and evaluate the effects of different computational methods.

### Research background and motivation

Vertical - axis wind turbines (VAWTs) have advantages in installation and operation, but their complex unsteady aerodynamic characteristics lead to low energy conversion efficiency. During the operation of VAWTs, the blades may experience dynamic stall or even deep stall, which makes the wake region full of multi - scale vortex structures, resulting in a highly unstable wake. Therefore, in - depth understanding of VAWT wake characteristics is crucial for optimizing their performance.

Since the computational cost of direct numerical simulation (DNS) is too high to be widely applied, this study aims to explore whether more economical turbulence models such as RANS can effectively simulate VAWT wakes and reveal flow characteristics through POD analysis. In addition, LES, as a high - fidelity simulation method, is also used to verify and compare the results.

### Main research content

- **Numerical simulation**: URANS and LES methods were used to perform numerical simulations of an H - shaped VAWT under different TSR conditions.
- **Model selection**: By comparing with existing experimental data, the most suitable turbulence model (such as the k - ω SST model) was selected.
- **POD analysis**: POD analysis was performed on the RANS and LES results to extract spatio - temporal patterns and their corresponding modal energies.
- **Result verification**: The simulation results were compared with experimental data to verify the effectiveness of different methods.

### Conclusions

The research shows that:
- The LES method is more accurate in predicting VAWT wake characteristics, especially in capturing the time and length - scale structures in the wake region.
- Although the RANS method can better capture the length and width of the wake region, it cannot accurately simulate the flow structure after the third POD mode.
- POD analysis reveals the main flow structures in the wake region under different TSR conditions, providing an important basis for understanding VAWT wake characteristics.

These findings are helpful for further optimizing the design and layout of VAWT, especially for the study of flow characteristics in compact configurations and large - scale applications.