Surface ferromagnetism in a chiral topological semimetal CoSi

N.N. Orlova,A.A. Avakyants,A.V. Timonina,N.N. Kolesnikov,E.V. Deviatov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.107.155137

2022-12-28

Abstract:Despite the chiral topological semimetal CoSi is known as bulk diamagnetic, it shows unusual surface ferromagnetism of debatable origin. The ferromagnetic ordering has been attributed to the distorted bonds, the superlattice of ordered vacancies, or even to topological surface textures due to the spin polarization in the neighboring Fermi arcs. We experimentally compare magnetization reversal curves for initially oxidized CoSi single crystals and cleaved samples with a fresh, oxide-free surface. While the oxidized CoSi samples do not show sizable ferromagnetism, the fresh CoSi surface gives a strong ferromagnetic response, which is accompanied by the pronounced modulation of the angle dependence of magnetization, as it can be expected for easy and hard axes in a ferromagnet. In addition to the first order reversal curves analysis, this observation allows us to distinguish between different mechanisms of the ferromagnetic ordering in CoSi single crystals. We conclude that the surface states-induced RKKY interaction between distorted bonds near the sample surface is responsible for the strong ferromagnetic multi-domain behavior for freshly cleaved samples.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the origin of surface ferromagnetism in the chiral topological semimetal cobalt silicide (CoSi). Although the bulk CoSi exhibits paramagnetism, its surface shows significant ferromagnetic behavior, and the specific mechanism of this phenomenon has not been clarified yet.

### Specific problems include:
1. **Source of surface ferromagnetism**: Researchers have proposed several possible mechanisms to explain the ferromagnetism on the CoSi surface, including:
- **Distorted bonds and dangling bonds**: Due to the asymmetry of the d - orbital electron spins of the transition metal (Co) near the surface under the exchange interaction.
- **Ordered - vacancy superlattice**: There are orderly arranged vacancies in the surface or near - surface regions.
- **Topological surface structure**: The topological surface texture caused by spin polarization in adjacent Fermi arcs.

2. **Distinguishing the influence of different mechanisms**: Distinguish the specific influence of these mechanisms on the contribution to surface ferromagnetism by experimental means.

### Experimental design:
To verify the above hypotheses, the researchers carried out the following experiments:
- **Comparison between oxidized and fresh samples**: The magnetization reversal curves (M - H curves) of the initially oxidized CoSi single - crystal samples and the freshly cut, oxide - layer - free fresh surface samples were compared.
- **Angle - dependence measurement**: The angle - dependence of the magnetization intensity with the change of the magnetic field direction was measured to identify the easy axis and the hard axis.

### Main findings:
- **Oxidized samples**: Show a weak hysteresis loop, mainly a paramagnetic response.
- **Fresh samples**: Show a strong ferromagnetic response, with obvious hysteresis loops and saturation magnetization, and the magnetization angle - dependence indicates the existence of clear easy and hard axes.

### Conclusion:
The research shows that the strong ferromagnetic multi - domain behavior on the fresh CoSi surface is caused by the surface - state - induced RKKY interaction, which occurs between the distorted bonds and dangling bonds near the surface. In addition, surface oxidation will severely disrupt this ferromagnetism, while the topological effect is relatively stable. Therefore, the experimental results support the surface - state - induced RKKY interaction as the main mechanism for the ferromagnetism on the CoSi surface.

### Related formulas:
The energy term of the RKKY interaction can be expressed as:
\[ H_{\text{RKKY}} = J S_1 S_2 \]
where \( J \) is the exchange integral, and \( S_1 \) and \( S_2 \) are the spins of two magnetic impurities respectively.

The system Hamiltonian can be written as:
\[ H = H_{\text{WSM}} - J_0 \sum_{i = 1,2} S_i s_i \]
where \( H_{\text{WSM}} \) is the low - energy Hamiltonian of the Weyl semimetal, \( J_0 \) is the exchange interaction strength, \( S_i \) is the spin of the \( i \) - th impurity, and \( s_i \) is the spin of the host electron.