Abstract:Supercooled first order phase transitions are typical of theories where conformal symmetry is predominantly spontaneously broken. In these theories the fate of the flat scalar direction is highly sensitive to the size and the scaling dimension of the explicit breaking deformations. For a given deformation, the coupling must lie in a particular region to realize a supercooled first order phase transition. We identify the supercooling window in weakly coupled theories and derive a fully analytical understanding of its boundaries. Mapping these boundaries allows us to identify the deformations enlarging the supercooling window and to characterize their dynamics analytically. For completeness we also discuss strongly coupled conformal field theories with an holographic dual, where the complete characterization of the supercooling window is challenged by calculability issues.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the occurrence conditions and dynamic behaviors of supercooled first - order phase transitions (PT) in weakly - coupled and strongly - coupled theories. Specifically, the paper focuses on the fact that under a given scalar potential, the coupling constant for realizing a supercooled first - order phase transition must be within a specific interval, which is called the "supercooling window". The goals of the paper are:
1. **Determine the boundaries of the supercooling window**: For the weakly - coupled theory, the author derives the analytical expressions of the boundaries of the supercooling window by analyzing the thermal corrections and quantum fluctuations of the scalar field, and verifies the consistency of these expressions with the numerical simulation results.
2. **Expand or shrink the supercooling window**: Explore how to expand or shrink the supercooling window by introducing non - thermal deformations (such as negative mass - squared terms or negative cubic terms). These deformations have a significant impact on the dynamics of the phase transition, especially having a direct impact on the intensity of the gravitational wave signal.
3. **The supercooling window in the strongly - coupled theory**: For the strongly - coupled conformal field theory (CFT) with holographic duality, it becomes more complicated to fully characterize the supercooling window due to computational difficulties. The author attempts to determine the boundaries of the supercooling window in these theories by improving the existing methods.
### Overview of the main content of the paper
#### Introduction
The paper first reviews the basic concepts and background of supercooled first - order phase transitions, pointing out that such phase transitions usually occur in theories with approximate scale invariance. The energy released during the phase transition can generate gravitational waves, and the detection of these gravitational wave signals is of great significance for understanding the physical processes in the early universe.
#### Definition of the supercooling window
- **Weakly - coupled theory**: In the simplest model, the scalar potential is mainly dominated by thermal corrections. By analyzing the tunneling rate and thermal corrections of the scalar field, the author determines the boundaries of the supercooling window and gives the analytical expressions.
- **Non - minimal construction**: By introducing non - thermal deformations (such as negative mass - squared terms or negative cubic terms), the supercooling window can be expanded or shrunk. These deformations have a significant impact on the dynamics of the phase transition, especially having a direct impact on the intensity of the gravitational wave signal.
- **Strongly - coupled theory**: For the strongly - coupled conformal field theory with holographic duality, it becomes more complicated to fully characterize the supercooling window due to computational difficulties. The author attempts to determine the boundaries of the supercooling window in these theories by improving the existing methods.
#### Mathematical derivations and results
- **Weakly - coupled theory**:
- **Scalar potential**: In the high - temperature expansion, the scalar potential can be expressed as \( V(\phi, T)=\frac{m^{2}(T)}{2} \phi^{2}-\frac{\delta(T)}{3} \phi^{3}+\frac{\lambda(T)}{4} \phi^{4}\), where \( m^{2}(T)\), \( \delta(T)\), and \( \lambda(T)\) are functions of temperature.
- **Tunneling rate**: The tunneling rate is controlled by the Euclidean action \( S_{3}\), and the analytical expression of \( S_{3}\) is obtained by numerical fitting.
- **Boundaries of the supercooling window**: By analyzing the tunneling rate and thermal corrections, the boundaries of the supercooling window are determined and the analytical expressions are given.
- **Strongly - coupled theory**:
- **Holographic duality**: In the Randall - Sundrum model, attempt to determine the boundaries of the supercooling window by improving the existing methods.
- **Computational challenges**: Due to computational difficulties, it becomes more complicated to fully characterize the supercooling window.
#### Conclusion
The paper systematically studies the conditions and dynamic behaviors of supercooled first - order phase transitions, especially in weakly - coupled and strongly - coupled theories. By introducing non - thermal deformations, the author shows how to expand or shrink the supercooling window and gives the corresponding analytical expressions. These results are of great significance for understanding the physical processes in the early universe and detecting gravitational wave signals.