Abstract:Abstract Since the 1970s, scientists have developed statistical methods intended to formalize detection of changes in global climate and to attribute such changes to relevant causal factors, natural and anthropogenic. Detection and attribution (D&A) of climate change trends is commonly performed using a variant of Hasselmann’s “optimal fingerprinting” method, which involves a linear regression of historical climate observations on corresponding output from numerical climate models. However, it has long been known in the field of time series analysis that regressions of “non-stationary” or “trending” variables are, in general, statistically inconsistent and often spurious. When non-stationarity is caused by “integrated” processes, as is likely the case for climate variables, consistency of least-squares estimators depends on “cointegration” of regressors. This study has shown, using an idealized linear-response-model framework, that if standard assumptions hold then the optimal fingerprinting estimator is consistent, and hence robust against spurious regression. In the case of global mean surface temperature (GMST), parameterizing abstract linear response models in terms of energy balance provides this result with physical interpretability. Hypothesis tests conducted using observations of historical GMST and simulation output from 13 CMIP6 general circulation models produced no evidence that standard assumptions required for consistency were violated. It is therefore concluded that, at least in the case of GMST, detection and attribution of climate change trends is very likely not spurious regression. Furthermore, detection of significant cointegration between observations and model output indicates that the least-squares estimator is “superconsistent”, with better convergence properties than might previously have been assumed. Finally, a new method has been developed for quantifying D&A uncertainty, exploiting the notion of cointegration to eliminate the need for pre-industrial control simulations.

Detecting and Attributing Change in Climate and Complex Systems: Foundations, Green's Functions, and Nonlinear Fingerprints

Could detection and attribution of climate change trends be spurious regression?

Revealing trends and persistent cycles of non-autonomous systems with operator-theoretic techniques: Applications to past and present climate dynamics

Fingerprinting Heatwaves and Cold Spells and Assessing Their Response to Climate Change using Large Deviation Theory

Experimental verification of the optimal fingerprint method for detecting climate change

Theoretical tools for understanding the climate crisis from Hasselmann's program and beyond

A Statistical Mechanical Approach for the Computation of the Climatic Response to General Forcings

Enhancing the description of multi-time-scale geophysical phenomena: Incorporating finite time Scale separation and feedback, illustrated with the case of a 1D variable of interest

Untangling Climate's Complexity: Methodological Insights

Detection and Attribution of Climate Change: a Regional Perspective

Fast and Slow Climate Responses to CO2 and Solar Forcing: A Linear Multivariate Regression Model Characterizing Transient Climate Change

Revealing trends and persistent cycles of non-autonomous systems with autonomous operator-theoretic techniques

Global Sensitivity and Domain-Selective Testing for Functional-Valued Responses: An Application to Climate Economy Models

Predicting Climate Change using Response Theory: Global Averages and Spatial Patterns

A globally coherent fingerprint of climate change impacts across natural systems

Forced signal and predictability in a prototype climate model: Implications for fingerprinting based detection in the presence of multidecadal natural variability

Robust global detection of forced changes in mean and extreme precipitation despite observational disagreement on the magnitude of change

Global sensitivity and domain‐selective testing for functional‐valued responses: An application to climate economy models

Spatially-Dependent Multiple Testing Under Model Misspecification, with Application to Detection of Anthropogenic Influence on Extreme Climate Events

Beyond Forcing Scenarios: Predicting Climate Change through Response Operators in a Coupled General Circulation Model

Evaluation of simulated responses to climate forcings: a flexible statistical framework using confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modelling – Part 1: Theory