Quantify the Causes of Causal Emergence: Critical Conditions of Uncertainty and Asymmetry in Causal Structure

Liye Jia,Fengyufan Yang,Ka Lok Man,Erick Purwanto,Sheng-Uei Guan,Jeremy Smith,Yutao Yue

2024-03-07

Abstract:Beneficial to advanced computing devices, models with massive parameters are increasingly employed to extract more information to enhance the precision in describing and predicting the patterns of objective systems. This phenomenon is particularly pronounced in research domains associated with deep learning. However, investigations of causal relationships based on statistical and informational theories have posed an interesting and valuable challenge to large-scale models in the recent decade. Macroscopic models with fewer parameters can outperform their microscopic counterparts with more parameters in effectively representing the system. This valuable situation is called "Causal Emergence." This paper introduces a quantification framework, according to the Effective Information and Transition Probability Matrix, for assessing numerical conditions of Causal Emergence as theoretical constraints of its occurrence. Specifically, our results quantitatively prove the cause of Causal Emergence. By a particular coarse-graining strategy, optimizing uncertainty and asymmetry within the model's causal structure is significantly more influential than losing maximum information due to variations in model scales. Moreover, by delving into the potential exhibited by Partial Information Decomposition and Deep Learning networks in the study of Causal Emergence, we discuss potential application scenarios where our quantification framework could play a role in future investigations of Causal Emergence.

Information Theory,Artificial Intelligence,Computational Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: **Explaining why coarse-graining strategies can lead to Causal Emergence (CE) by quantifying the key conditions of CE, namely uncertainty and asymmetry**.

Specifically, the goals of the paper are:
1. **Define the intrinsic properties of the model**: Consider uncertainty and asymmetry as factors affecting the effectiveness of discrete models.
2. **Introduce a quantification framework**: Calculate the specific characteristics required for micro and macro models when CE occurs.
3. **Provide a theoretical benchmark**: Offer mathematical constraints for future CE research to help deepen the understanding of the CE phenomenon.

The main contributions of the paper include:
- **Quantifying uncertainty and asymmetry**: By adjusting parameters to generate synthetic transition probability matrices (TPM) with controllable uncertainty and asymmetry, thereby identifying the sufficient and necessary conditions for the occurrence of CE.
- **Validating the importance of reducing asymmetry**: Demonstrating the importance of reducing asymmetry for coarse-graining strategies to bring about CE.
- **Discussing future applications**: Exploring potential improvements and application prospects of the quantification framework in CE research.

Through this work, the paper aims to provide a more concrete theoretical foundation and numerical constraints for the study of CE, promoting further development in this field.