Estimating Time-Varying Direct and Indirect Causal Excursion Effects with Longitudinal Binary Outcomes

Jieru Shi,Zhenke Wu,Walter Dempsey
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2212.01472
2022-12-03
Abstract:Construction of just-in-time adaptive interventions, such as prompts delivered by mobile apps to promote and maintain behavioral change, requires knowledge about time-varying moderated effects to inform when and how we deliver intervention options. Micro-randomized trials (MRT) have emerged as a sequentially randomized design to gather requisite data for effect estimation. The existing literature (Qian et al., 2020; Boruvka et al., 2018; Dempsey et al., 2020) has defined a general class of causal estimands, referred to as "causal excursion effects", to assess the time-varying moderated effect. However, there is limited statistical literature on how to address potential between-cluster treatment effect heterogeneity and within-cluster interference in a sequential treatment setting for longitudinal binary outcomes. In this paper, based on a cluster conceptualization of the potential outcomes, we define a larger class of direct and indirect causal excursion effects for proximal and lagged binary outcomes, and propose a new inferential procedure that addresses effect heterogeneity and interference. We provide theoretical guarantees of consistency and asymptotic normality of the estimator. Extensive simulation studies confirm our theory empirically and show the proposed procedure provides consistent point estimator and interval estimates with valid coverage. Finally, we analyze a data set from a multi-institution MRT study to assess the time-varying moderated effects of mobile prompts upon binary study engagement outcomes.
Methodology,Statistics Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to estimate the time - varying direct and indirect causal excursion effects in longitudinal binary outcomes, especially in the presence of cluster structures. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to deal with the potential inter - cluster treatment effect heterogeneity and intra - cluster interference problems in Micro - Randomized Trials (MRTs). These problems are often overlooked in traditional MRT analyses, and this paper proposes a new method to solve these problems, thereby more accurately evaluating the impact of mobile interventions on individual behavior change. ### Main Contributions 1. **Define New Causal Excursion Effects**: - **Direct Causal Excursion Effect**: Consider the individual treatment effect given the cluster state. - **Pair - wise Indirect Causal Excursion Effect**: Consider the impact of an individual's treatment state on another untreated individual within the same cluster. 2. **Propose New Estimation Methods**: - **Cluster - based Estimator of the Marginal Excursion Effect (C - EMEE)**: Used to estimate the direct and pair - wise indirect causal excursion effects while considering the cluster structure. 3. **Theoretical Guarantees**: - Provide theoretical guarantees for the consistency and asymptotic normality of the estimators. 4. **Simulation Studies**: - Verify the effectiveness of the new method through extensive simulation studies, indicating that this method can provide consistent point estimates and valid confidence intervals. 5. **Practical Applications**: - Apply the new method to the data of the Intern Health Study (IHS) to evaluate the impact of mobile prompt notifications on participants' daily mood survey completion. ### Background and Motivation - **Micro - Randomized Trials (MRTs)**: MRTs are a sequential random design for collecting data required to evaluate treatment effects. Each subject will be randomly assigned to different treatment options multiple times during the trial process. - **Longitudinal Binary Outcomes**: The main outcomes of many MRTs are longitudinal binary variables, such as whether a user participates in an application or completes a task. - **Cluster Structures**: In practical applications, subjects usually have a natural cluster structure. For example, interns come from different hospitals and majors, which leads to inter - cluster treatment effect heterogeneity and intra - cluster interference problems. ### Methods - **Assumptions**: - **Consistency**: The observed value is equal to the corresponding potential outcome. - **Positivity**: If the joint density is greater than zero, the probability of treatment assignment is greater than zero. - **Sequential Ignorability**: The potential outcomes are independent of treatment assignment given the observed history. - **Identification Results**: - Through the assumptions, the causal excursion effects can be expressed as a function of the observed data. - **Estimation Methods**: - **Direct Effect Estimation**: Use the C - EMEE method to estimate the direct effect. - **Pair - wise Indirect Effect Estimation**: Use a similar method to estimate the pair - wise indirect effect. ### Conclusion The new method proposed in this paper can more accurately estimate the time - varying direct and indirect causal excursion effects in the presence of cluster structures, providing an important tool for the design and evaluation of mobile health interventions.