Abstract:How, and to what extent, does an interconnected financial system endogenously amplify external shocks? This paper attempts to reconcile some apparently different views emerged after the 2008 crisis regarding the nature and the relevance of contagion in financial networks. We develop a common framework encompassing several network contagion models and show that, regardless of the shock distribution and the network topology, precise ordering relationships on the level of aggregate systemic losses hold among models. We argue that the extent of contagion crucially depends on the amount of information that each model assumes to be available to market players. Under no uncertainty about the network structure and values of external assets, the well-known Eisenberg and Noe (2001) model applies, which delivers the lowest level of contagion. This is due to a property of loss conservation: aggregate losses after contagion are equal to the losses incurred by those institutions initially hit by a shock. This property implies that many contagion analyses rule out by construction any loss amplification, treating de facto an interconnected system as a single aggregate entity, where losses are simply mutualised. Under higher levels of uncertainty, as captured for instance by the DebtRank model, losses become non-conservative and get compounded through the network. This has important policy implications: by reducing the levels of uncertainty in times of distress (e.g. by obtaining specific data on the network) policymakers would be able to move towards more conservative scenarios. Empirically, we compare the magnitude of contagion across models on a sample of the largest European banks during the years 2006-2016. In particular, we analyse contagion effects as a function of the size of the shock and the type of external assets shocked.

Endogenous distress contagion in a dynamic interbank model: how possible future losses may spell doom today

Distress and default contagion in financial networks

Interbank Contagion: An Agent-Based Model Approach to Endogenously Formed Networks

Dynamic Default Contagion in Heterogeneous Interbank Systems

An SPDE Model for Systemic Risk with Endogenous Contagion

Rethinking Financial Contagion

Managing Default Contagion in Inhomogeneous Financial Networks

Can banks default overnight? Modeling endogenous contagion on O/N interbank market

Contagion risk in the interbank market: a probabilistic approach to cope with incomplete structural information

Uncertainty, non-linear contagion and the credit quality channel: An application to the Spanish interbank market

A Dynamic Default Contagion Model: From Eisenberg-Noe to the Mean Field

Financial Network and Systemic Risk—A Dynamic Model

BANK PANICS AND FIRE SALES, INSOLVENCY AND ILLIQUIDITY

A network model of financial system resilience

Prediction of Systemic Risk Contagion Based on a Dynamic Complex Network Model Using Machine Learning Algorithm

Capital Regulation under Price Impacts and Dynamic Financial Contagion

Dynamic Interaction Between Asset Prices and Bank Behavior: A Systemic Risk Perspective

Shock amplification in an interconnected financial system of banks and investment funds

Dynamic Contagion in a Banking System with Births and Defaults

An extension of Davis and Lo's contagion model

Systemic Risk with Multi-Channel Risk Contagion in the Interbank Market