Optimal sizing of renewable energy storage: A comparative study of hydrogen and battery system considering degradation and seasonal storage

Son Tay Le,Tuan Ngoc Nguyen,Dac-Khuong Bui,Tuan Duc Ngo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2023.120817

2022-11-15

Abstract:Renewable energy storage (RES) is essential to address the intermittence issues of renewable energy systems, thereby enhancing the system stability and reliability. This study presents an optimisation study of sizing and operational strategy parameters of a grid-connected photovoltaic (PV)-hydrogen/battery systems using a Multi-Objective Modified Firefly Algorithm (MOMFA). An operational strategy that utilises the ability of hydrogen to store energy over a long time was also investigated. The proposed method was applied to a real-world distributed energy project located in the tropical climate zone. To further demonstrate the robustness and versatility of the method, another synthetic test case was examined for a location in the subtropical weather zone, which has a high seasonal mismatch. The performance of the proposed MOMFA method is compared with the NSGA-II method, which has been widely used to design renewable energy storage systems in the literature. The result shows that MOMFA is more accurate and robust than NSGA-II owing to the complex and dynamic nature of energy storage system. The optimisation results show that battery storage systems, as a mature technology, yield better economic performance than current hydrogen storage systems. However, it is proven that hydrogen storage systems provide better techno-economic performance and can be a viable long-term storage solution when high penetration of renewable energy is required. The study also proves that the proposed long-term operational strategy can lower component degradation, enhance efficiency, and increase the total economic performance of hydrogen storage systems. The findings of this study can support the implementation of energy storage systems for renewable energy.

Optimization and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: How to optimize the scale and operation strategies of renewable energy storage systems (RES) to deal with the intermittency problem of renewable energy systems, thereby improving the stability and reliability of the system. Specifically, the research focuses on the optimal design and operation strategies of grid - connected photovoltaic - hydrogen/battery systems, especially considering the effects of component degradation, price fluctuations, and seasonal energy storage requirements.

### Research Background and Problem Description

1. **Intermittency Problem of Renewable Energy**
Renewable energy (such as solar energy and wind energy) is intermittent and uncontrollable, which leads to problems such as supply - demand mismatch, power quality problems, and network constraints. Therefore, an energy storage system (ESS) is required to store energy and use it when needed.

2. **Limitations of Existing Research**
- Most research focuses on optimizing the scale of energy storage systems under fixed operation strategies. These methods are more suitable for short - term energy storage and cannot fully utilize the long - term energy storage potential of hydrogen energy.
- Previous research has not fully considered the dynamic changes of system components, such as future electricity price changes or component aging effects.

3. **Optimization Objectives**
- **Economy**: Maximize the net present value (NPV), that is, improve economic benefits by reducing electricity bill expenditures and system costs.
- **Technical and Environmental Objectives**: Maximize the self - sufficiency rate (SSR), that is, the proportion of power demand met by the renewable energy system, thereby reducing dependence on the traditional power grid.

### Research Methods and Innovation Points

1. **Multi - objective Optimization Algorithm**
Use the improved firefly algorithm (MOMFA) for multi - objective optimization. The optimization objectives include NPV and SSR. MOMFA performs well in dealing with complex and dynamic energy storage system optimization problems.

2. **Long - term Operation Strategy**
Propose an optimized long - term operation strategy (OLDS). This strategy adjusts the energy storage and release strategies according to seasonal characteristics (such as sunny months and cloudy months) to fully utilize the advantages of hydrogen energy in seasonal energy storage.

3. **Consideration of Component Degradation and Price Fluctuations**
In the optimization process, the aging effects of components and future electricity price changes are considered, making the optimization results more in line with practical applications.

### Main Contributions

- **Framework Optimization**: Propose a framework for simultaneously optimizing the scale and operation strategies of energy storage systems, considering factors such as electricity price prediction, solar output depreciation, and component aging.
- **New Operation Strategy**: Introduce long - term operation strategies in two different operation modes (summer and winter) to fully utilize the potential of hydrogen energy in seasonal energy storage.
- **Algorithm Application**: Apply MOMFA to energy storage system optimization for the first time and verify its superior performance.
- **Case Analysis**: Verify the robustness and universality of this method through actual cases in tropical and subtropical regions.
- **Economic Performance Comparison**: Compare the economic performances of hydrogen energy and battery energy storage systems, and evaluate the market readiness level and future potential of the hydrogen energy system.

Through these studies, the paper provides theoretical support and technical guidance for achieving efficient and reliable renewable energy storage systems.