Sociophysics: a new approach of sociological collective behaviour. I. Mean-behaviour description of a strike

Serge Galam,Yuval Gefen,Yonathan Shapir

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2211.07041

2022-11-14

Abstract:A new approach to the understanding of sociological collective behaviour, based on the framework of critical phenomena in physics, is presented. The first step consists of constructing a simple mean-behaviour model and applying it to a strike process in a plant. The model comprises only a limited number of parameters characteristic of the plant considered and of the society. A dissatisfaction function is introduced with a basic principle stating that the stable state of the plant is a state, which minimizes this function. It is found that the plant can be in one of two phases: the "collective phase" and the "individual phase". These two phases are separated by a critical point, in the neighbourhood of which the system is very sensitive to small changes in the parameters. The collective phase includes a region of parameters for which the system has two possible states: a "work state" and a "strike state". The actual state of the system depends on the parameters and on the "history of the system". The irreversibility of the transition between these two states indicates the existence of metastable states. For these particular states, the effect of small groups of workers or of a small perturbation in the system results in drastic changes in the state of the plant. Other non-trivial implications of the model, as well as possible extensions and refinements of the approach, are discussed.

Physics and Society,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the problem of how to understand and describe collective behavior in sociology through the methods of physics, particularly the collective behavior during factory strikes. Specifically, the authors propose a simple Mean-Behaviour Model (M.B. Model) based on the framework of critical phenomena in physical systems and apply it to the process of factory strikes.

### Main Issues:
1. **How to describe collective behavior in sociology using physical methods?**
- The authors attempt to apply methods used in physics to describe the collective behavior of multi-particle systems to sociology, particularly to the collective behavior in factory strikes.

2. **How to construct a simple model to describe the process of a factory strike?**
- The authors propose a Mean-Behaviour Model, which describes the behavior of workers in a factory by introducing some key parameters (such as social permeability, effective wage, contact intensity, etc.).

3. **How to determine the stable state of the system?**
- The authors introduce the Principle of Minimum Dissatisfaction (PMD), determining the stable state of the system by minimizing the dissatisfaction function \( F \).

### Specific Goals:
- **Understanding the mechanism of collective behavior**: Using physical methods to understand how the collective behavior of workers during a factory strike is formed.
- **Identifying behavioral characteristics at different stages**: Distinguishing between individual and collective stages and analyzing the behavioral characteristics of the system under different parameter conditions.
- **Exploring the sensitivity and stability of the system**: Studying the sensitivity of the system near critical points and the impact of small disturbances on the system state.

### Key Elements of the Model:
- **Individual productivity**: Represented by \( \mu_i \), indicating the productivity of the \( i \)-th worker, ranging from -1 (strike) to +1 (maximum production).
- **Contact intensity**: Represented by \( J_{ij} \), indicating the interaction strength between workers.
- **Average productivity**: Represented by \( M \), indicating the average productivity of the entire factory.
- **Effective wage**: Represented by \( H \), indicating the wages and other benefits of the workers.
- **Social permeability**: Represented by \( T \), indicating the workers' responsiveness to the social atmosphere.
- **Dissatisfaction function**: Represented by \( F \), indicating the level of dissatisfaction in the system, with the stable state determined by minimizing \( F \).

Through these elements, the authors successfully constructed a model that can describe the process of a factory strike and revealed some important characteristics of collective behavior, such as the system's bistability, historical dependence, and high sensitivity to small disturbances.