Braid Protected Topological Band Structures with Unpaired Exceptional Points

J. Lukas K. König,Kang Yang,Jan Carl Budich,Emil J. Bergholtz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.L042010
2023-10-29
Abstract:We demonstrate the existence of topologically stable unpaired exceptional points (EPs), and construct simple non-Hermitian (NH) tight-binding models exemplifying such remarkable nodal phases. While fermion doubling, i.e. the necessity of compensating the topological charge of a stable nodal point by an anti-dote, rules out a direct counterpart of our findings in the realm of Hermitian semimetals, here we derive how noncommuting braids of complex energy levels may stabilize unpaired EPs. Drawing on this insight, we reveal the occurrence of a single, unpaired EP, manifested as a non-Abelian monopole in the Brillouin zone of a minimal three-band model. This third-order degeneracy represents a sweet spot within a larger topological phase that cannot be fully gapped by any local perturbation. Instead, it may only split into simpler (second-order) degeneracies that can only gap out by pairwise annihilation after having moved around inequivalent large circles of the Brillouin zone. Our results imply the incompleteness of a topological classification based on winding numbers, due to non-Abelian representations of the braid group intertwining three or more complex energy levels, and provide insights into the topological robustness of non-Hermitian systems and their non-Abelian phase transitions.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Mathematical Physics,Optics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore and demonstrate the existence of topologically stable unpaired exceptional points (EPs) in periodic systems. Specifically, the authors construct simple non - Hermitian (NH) tight - binding models to exemplify these unique nodal phases. They study how these unpaired EPs can be stabilized through the non - commuting braids of complex energy levels and reveal the appearance of a single unpaired EP in the Brillouin zone (BZ) of a minimal three - band model, which is manifested as a non - Abelian monopole. #### Main problems and background 1. **Challenges to the traditional fermion doubling theorem**: - In Hermitian semimetals, due to the fermion doubling theorem, topological charges need to be compensated, so stable nodal points must appear in pairs. - However, in non - Hermitian systems, this limitation can be broken, making unpaired EPs possible. 2. **Incompleteness of topological classification**: - The topological classification of non - Hermitian systems cannot rely solely on winding numbers because the representation forms of the non - Abelian braid group intertwine three or more complex energy levels. - This means that traditional topological classification methods are insufficient to describe these complex non - Hermitian systems. 3. **Topological robustness**: - The researchers demonstrate the robustness of these non - Hermitian topological band structures, that is, they will not disappear due to local perturbations but need to be eliminated after moving along non - trivial loops in the BZ. #### Specific objectives - **Prove the existence of unpaired EPs**: By constructing specific non - Hermitian tight - binding models, show the existence and stability of these unpaired EPs. - **Explain their topological robustness**: Analyze in detail the topological properties of these EPs, especially how they remain stable through non - commuting braid structures. - **Provide new physical insights**: Reveal the characteristics of these unpaired EPs, including their high - order degeneracy and associated Fermi arcs, as well as their relationship with non - Abelian phase transitions in non - Hermitian systems. ### Conclusion The authors successfully demonstrate the existence of topologically stable unpaired EPs in non - Hermitian systems and explain the underlying physical mechanisms through specific models and theoretical analysis. This finding not only challenges the traditional fermion doubling theorem but also provides a new perspective for understanding the topological properties of non - Hermitian systems. In addition, similar non - Hermitian multi - band systems have also been experimentally realized, further verifying the practical significance of this theory.