Pre-analysis protocol for an observational study on the effects of adolescent sports participation on health in early adulthood

Ajinkya H Kokandakar,Yuzhou Lin,Steven Jin,Jordan Weiss,Amanda R Rabinowitz,Reuben A Buford May,Dylan Small,Sameer K Deshpande
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2211.02104
2023-11-30
Abstract:We will study the impact of adolescent sports participation on early-adulthood health using longitudinal data from the National Study of Youth and Religion. We focus on two primary outcomes measured at ages 23--28 -- self-rated health and total score on the PHQ9 Patient Depression Questionnaire -- and control for several potential confounders related to demographics and family socioeconomic status. Comparing outcomes between sports participants and matched non-sports participants with similar confounders is straightforward. Unfortunately, an analysis based on such a broad exposure cannot probe the possibility that participation in certain types of sports (e.g., collision sports like football or soccer) may have larger effects on health than others. In this study, we introduce a hierarchy of exposure definitions, ranging from broad (participation in any after-school organized activity) to narrow (e.g., participation in limited-contact sports). We will perform separate matched observational studies, one for each definition, to estimate the health effects of several levels of sports participation. In order to conduct these studies while maintaining a fixed family-wise error rate, we deployed an ordered testing approach that exploits the logical relationships between exposure definitions. Our study will also consider several secondary outcomes including body mass index, life satisfaction, and problematic drinking behavior.
Applications
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to investigate the impact of adolescent participation in sports activities on early adulthood health. Specifically, the researchers utilize longitudinal data from the National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR) to explore the specific effects of sports participation during adolescence on health outcomes in early adulthood. ### Research Background Existing research indicates that sports activities have positive effects on the physical, emotional, and psychological health of adolescents. Many studies focus on adolescents' participation in school-organized team sports, revealing the impact of sports activities on students' mental health. For example, participation in school sports during adolescence is a significant predictor of fewer depressive symptoms, lower perceived stress, and higher self-rated mental health in early adulthood. Additionally, more involvement in team sports predicts fewer depressive and anxiety symptoms at subsequent time points, suggesting that the impact of sports activities extends beyond the adolescent competition period. However, the existing research results are inconsistent regarding different types of sports activities (such as individual vs. team sports), participation intensity (such as participation in multiple sports or long-term involvement), and the specific types of sports on adolescent well-being. For instance, although athletes in individual sports (such as swimming, cross-country, fencing, track and field, etc.) report fewer anxiety or depressive symptoms than non-athletes, they report more anxiety or depressive symptoms compared to team sports athletes. This may be partly due to the social support from other team members that team sports athletes receive, which can alleviate the performance pressure faced by individual sports participants. ### Research Objectives The primary goal of this study is to assess the specific impact of adolescent sports participation on early adulthood health, considering the relative benefits and risks of different types of sports activities (contact, limited contact, and non-contact sports). Specifically, the researchers will focus on two main outcome indicators: self-rated health status and the total score of the PHQ-9 depression questionnaire. Additionally, the study will consider several secondary outcome indicators, including body mass index, life satisfaction, and problematic drinking behavior. ### Methods The researchers use the NSYR dataset, which includes four waves of data collected in 2002-2003 (Wave 1), 2005 (Wave 2), 2007-2008 (Wave 3), and 2013 (Wave 4). Information on sports activities was recorded in Wave 1. The researchers will compare health outcomes between different exposure groups (participation in different types of sports activities) and the control group (no participation in any sports activities) using a matched observational study approach. To control for potential confounding factors, the researchers adjusted for multiple variables related to demographics and socioeconomic status. They also introduced a hierarchical exposure definition system, ranging from broad (participation in any extracurricular activities) to narrow (participation in specific types of sports activities), and used an ordered testing method to control the family-wise error rate. ### Conclusion Through this study, the researchers hope to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the specific impact of adolescent sports participation on early adulthood health and provide scientific evidence for future interventions.