Fernanda Torres,Sujoy K. Modak,Alfredo Aranda
Abstract:We argue, in light of Collapse Model interpretation of quantum theory, that the fundamental division between the quantum and classical behaviors is analogous to the division of thermodynamic phases. A specific relationship between the collapse parameter $(\lambda)$ and the collapse length scale ($r_C$) plays the role of the coexistence curve in usual thermodynamic phase diagrams. We further claim that our functional relationship between $\lambda$ and $r_C$ is strongly supported by the existing IGEX collaboration data. This result is preceded by a self-contained discussion of quantum measurement theory and the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) model applied to the free wavepacket dynamics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the boundary problem between quantum mechanics and classical physics, especially how to draw the line between quantum and classical behaviors. Specifically, the authors explore new insights into the quantum - classical boundary based on Collapse Models. They propose that this boundary may be similar to the phase - separation phenomenon in thermodynamic phase transitions. In the paper, by introducing a specific relation, that is, the relation between the collapse parameter \( \lambda \) and the collapse length scale \( r_C \), to simulate the coexistence curve in the usual thermodynamic phase diagram. This relation is strongly supported by the data from the International Germanium Experiment (IGEX) collaboration.
### Core problems of the paper
1. **Quantum measurement problem**: The paper discusses the "measurement problem" in the quantum measurement theory. That is, when a system is measured by a quantum device, it will inevitably fall into an uninterruptible von Neumann chain (VNC), and the collapse model can solve this problem.
2. **Quantum - classical boundary**: The authors propose that the identification and classification of quantum and classical "phases" may be similar to the identification and classification of phases in thermodynamic, magnetic or quark - gluon plasma (QGP) systems.
3. **Application of the collapse model**: By applying the Ghirardi - Rimini - Weber (GRW) model, study the dynamics of free wave packets, and by introducing the collapse parameter \( \lambda \) and the collapse length scale \( r_C \), explore how these parameters affect the expansion and collapse processes of the wave packets.
4. **Support from experimental data**: The theoretical results in the paper are supported by the IGEX experimental data, which verify the functional relationship between the collapse parameter \( \lambda \) and the collapse length scale \( r_C \).
### Main conclusions
- **Relationship between collapse parameter and length scale**: The author proposes a specific functional relationship \( \lambda \propto r_C^2 \) and verifies this in the dynamics of free wave packets.
- **Quantum - classical phase diagram**: By analogy with the thermodynamic phase diagram, the author constructs a quantum - classical phase diagram, in which different values of \( \lambda \) and \( r_C \) correspond to different physical behaviors.
- **Experimental constraints**: Using the IGEX experimental data, the author further constrains the value range of the collapse parameter \( \lambda \), making it more precise.
### Formula summary
- **Wave packet evolution equation**:
\[
U|\psi_0\rangle|A_0\rangle = \sum_n c_n |\psi_n\rangle |A_n\rangle
\]
- **Evolution of density matrix**:
\[
\frac{d\rho}{dt}=-\frac{i}{\hbar}[H, \rho]+\lambda(T_q[\rho]-\rho)
\]
- **Differential equation of free wave packet system**:
\[
\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\langle q'|\rho(t)|q''\rangle=\frac{i\hbar}{2m}\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial q'^2}-\frac{\partial^2}{\partial q''^2}\right)\langle q'|\rho(t)|q''\rangle-\lambda\left(1 - e^{-\frac{\alpha}{4}(q' - q'')^2}\right)\langle q'|\rho(t)|q''\rangle
\]
- **Expansion formula of wave packet width**:
\[
\langle\Delta q_{\text{GRW}}\rangle(t)=\sqrt{\Delta q_0^2+\frac{\hbar^2}{4m^2}\Del