From Silicon Shield to Carbon Lock-in ? The Environmental Footprint of Electronic Components Manufacturing in Taiwan (2015-2020)

Gauthier Roussilhe,Thibault Pirson,Mathieu Xhonneux,David Bol

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2209.12523

2022-09-26

Abstract:Taiwan plans to rapidly increase its industrial production capacity of electronic components while concurrently setting policies for its ecological transition. Given that the island is responsible for the manufacturing of a significant part of worldwide electronics components, the sustainability of the Taiwanese electronics industry is therefore of critical interest. In this paper, we survey the environmental footprint of 16 Taiwanese electronic components manufacturers (ECM) using corporate sustainability responsibility reports (CSR). Based on data from 2015 to 2020, this study finds out that our sample of 16 manufacturers increased its greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions by 7.5\% per year, its final energy and electricity consumption by 8.8\% and 8.9\%, and the water usage by 6.1\%. We show that the volume of manufactured electronic components and the environmental footprints compiled in this study are strongly correlated, which suggests that relative efficiency gains are not sufficient to curb the environmental footprint at the national scale. Given the critical nature of electronics industry for Taiwan's geopolitics and economics, the observed increase of energy consumption and the slow renewable energy roll-out, these industrial activities could create a carbon lock-in, blocking the Taiwanese government from achieving its carbon reduction goals and its sustainability policies. Besides, the European Union, the USA or even China aim at developing an industrial ecosystem targeting sub-10nm CMOS technology nodes similar to Taiwan. This study thus provides important insights regarding the environmental implications associated with such a technology roadmap. All data and calculation models used in this study are provided as supplementary material.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of assessing the environmental footprint of Taiwan's electronic component manufacturing industry during the period from 2015 to 2020 and exploring its impact on Taiwan's national sustainable development goals. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Growth of Environmental Footprint**: The paper investigates the environmental footprint of 16 Taiwanese electronic component manufacturers (ECM), including greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, final energy and electricity consumption, and water usage. The study found that during the period from 2015 to 2020, these companies' annual greenhouse gas emissions increased by 7.5%, final energy and electricity consumption increased by 8.8% and 8.9% respectively, and water usage increased by 6.1%.

2. **Relationship Between Production Volume and Environmental Footprint**: The study shows a strong correlation between the number of electronic components manufactured and the environmental footprint, indicating that relative efficiency improvements are insufficient to curb the environmental impact at the national level.

3. **Carbon Lock-in Risk**: Given the geopolitical and economic importance of Taiwan's electronics industry, along with the increase in energy consumption and the slow promotion of renewable energy, these industrial activities may lead to carbon lock-in, hindering the Taiwanese government's efforts to achieve its carbon reduction targets and sustainable development policies.

4. **Impact in an International Context**: The European Union, the United States, and even China are striving to develop industrial ecosystems similar to Taiwan's sub-10nm CMOS technology nodes. Therefore, this study also provides important insights into the environmental impact of such technological roadmaps.

Through these analyses, the paper aims to assess whether the rapid development of Taiwan's electronics industry aligns with its national sustainable development blueprint and to provide a reference for other economies (such as the EU) in repositioning their electronic manufacturing industries.