Contextuality as a Precondition for Quantum Entanglement

Martin Plávala,Otfried Gühne

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.100201

2024-07-19

Abstract:Quantum theory features several phenomena which can be considered as resources for information processing tasks. Some of these effects, such as entanglement, arise in a nonlocal scenario, where a quantum state is distributed between different parties. Other phenomena, such as contextuality, can be observed if quantum states are prepared and then subjected to sequences of measurements. We use robust remote state preparation to connect the nonlocal and sequential scenarios and provide an intimate connection between different resources: We prove that entanglement in a nonlocal scenario can arise only if there is preparation and measurement contextuality in the corresponding sequential scenario and that the absence of entanglement implies the absence of contextuality. As a direct consequence, our result allows us to translate any inequality for testing preparation and measurement contextuality into an entanglement test; in addition, entanglement witnesses can be used to design novel contextuality inequalities.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between quantum entanglement and preparation and measurement contextuality (P&M contextuality) and demonstrates the close connection between quantum entanglement in nonlocal scenarios (NLS) and P&M contextuality in sequential scenarios (SQS).

The core contributions of the paper can be summarized as follows:

1. **Theoretical Background**: The paper first introduces the two main research scenarios in quantum information processing—nonlocal scenarios and sequential scenarios. In nonlocal scenarios, two distant participants (usually called Alice and Bob) share a quantum state and perform different measurements; whereas in sequential scenarios, one party (e.g., Bob) prepares a quantum state and passes it to another party (e.g., Alice), who then performs measurements.

2. **Key Findings**: The authors prove that quantum entanglement in nonlocal scenarios can only occur if there is P&M contextuality in sequential scenarios. Specifically, if a quantum state exhibits entanglement in a nonlocal scenario, there must be preparation and measurement contextuality in the corresponding sequential scenario. Conversely, if there is no entanglement, there will be no contextuality in the sequential scenario.

3. **Applications of Results**:
- The paper further demonstrates how inequalities used to test P&M contextuality can be converted into entanglement witnesses.
- Similarly, entanglement witnesses can be used to design new contextuality inequalities.
- These findings are significant for understanding the security of quantum key distribution and the advantages of quantum information processing.

4. **Experimental Verification**: The results of the paper imply that any experiment verifying the entanglement of quantum states (e.g., by observing quantum steering or violating Bell inequalities) will also directly verify the P&M contextuality in the corresponding system.

In summary, the main goal of this paper is to reveal the profound connection between quantum entanglement and P&M contextuality and to provide a theoretical framework for the conversion between these two quantum resources. This achievement not only deepens our understanding of key resources in quantum information processing but also provides strong support for designing new experimental schemes and enhancing the security of quantum technologies.