Evidence for suppression of collective magnetism in Fe-Ag granular multilayers

László F. Kiss,László Bujdosó,Dénes Kaptás

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmmm.2023.171217

2023-10-27

Abstract:Evidence for the suppression of collective magnetic behavior of dipolarly interacting Fe nanoparticles is found in Fe-Ag granular multilayers. Interaction of Fe particles located in neighboring Fe layers is studied as a function of the nominal thickness of the Ag layer in between only two Fe layers. The surprisingly increasing interaction with increasing Ag-layer thickness, verified by memory-effect measurements, is explained by the formation of pinholes in the Ag layer at small Ag thicknesses, allowing direct ferromagnetic coupling between Fe particles in neighboring Fe layers which may hinder the frustration of superspins favored by dipolar interactions. At larger Ag thicknesses, the Ag layer is continuous without pinholes and frustration leads to the appearance of the superspin-glass state. The effect of increasing interactions correlates well with the growing deviation at low temperatures of the measured field-cooled (FC) magnetization from the interaction-free FC curve calculated by a model based on the relaxation of two-level systems. Similar phenomenon is reported in a recently published paper (Sánchez et al., Small 2022, 18, 2106762) where a dense nanoparticle system is studied. The collective magnetic behavior of the particles due to dipolar interactions is suppressed when the anisotropy energy of the individual particles exceeds a certain threshold.

Materials Science,Applied Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are as follows: In the Fe - Ag multilayer films, study how the magnetic interactions between Fe nanoparticles change with the variation of the thickness of the Ag layer, and explore the influence of this change on the collective magnetic behaviors (such as superparamagnetism, superspin - glass state, etc.).

Specifically, the authors analyzed the magnetic behaviors in the Fe - Ag multilayer films through experiments and theoretical model analysis, especially focusing on the following issues:

1. **Interaction mechanisms between Fe nanoparticles**:
- How does the dipole - dipole interaction between Fe nanoparticles change with the thickness of the Ag layer?
- Are there other factors (such as RKKY exchange interaction or discontinuity of the Ag layer) that affect these interactions?

2. **Suppression phenomena of collective magnetic behaviors**:
- When the Ag layer is thin, why does the interaction between Fe nanoparticles increase rather than decrease?
- How does this enhanced interaction affect the collective magnetic behavior of the system, for example, the formation of the superspin - glass state?

3. **Physical mechanisms for explaining experimental results**:
- Why is the memory effect observed in the thinner Ag layer weaker, while it is enhanced in the thicker Ag layer?
- Can this phenomenon be explained by the direct ferromagnetic coupling caused by pinholes in the Ag layer?

Through the research of these problems, the authors hope to reveal the complexity of magnetic interactions and the regulation mechanisms of collective magnetic behaviors in Fe - Ag multilayer films. This not only helps to understand the physical properties of magnetic materials at the nanoscale, but also provides a theoretical basis for designing nanocomposites with specific magnetic properties.

### Key conclusions
- **Influence of Ag layer thickness on magnetic interactions**: As the thickness of the Ag layer increases, the interaction between Fe nanoparticles is enhanced, which is manifested as the enhancement of the memory effect.
- **Pinhole effect**: In the thinner Ag layer, the presence of pinholes enables the direct ferromagnetic coupling between Fe nanoparticles in adjacent Fe layers, thus suppressing the formation of collective magnetic behaviors.
- **Suppression of collective magnetic behaviors**: When the Ag layer is thin, the direct coupling between Fe nanoparticles hinders the formation of the superspin - glass state; while when the Ag layer is thick, the dipole - dipole interaction dominates and promotes the appearance of the superspin - glass state.

These findings are of great significance for understanding and regulating the collective magnetic behaviors of magnetic materials at the nanoscale.