Abstract:The origin of life and the detection of alien life have historically been treated as separate scientific research problems. However, they are not strictly independent. Here, we discuss the need for a better integration of the sciences of life detection and origins of life. Framing these dual problems within the formalism of Bayesian hypothesis testing, we demonstrate via simple examples how high confidence in life detection claims require either (1) a strong prior hypothesis about the existence of life in a particular alien environment, or conversely, (2) signatures of life that are not susceptible to false positives. As a case study, we discuss the role of priors and hypothesis testing in recent results reporting potential detection of life in the venusian atmosphere and in the icy plumes of Enceladus. While many current leading biosignature candidates are subject to false positives because they are not definitive of life, our analyses demonstrate why it is necessary to shift focus to candidate signatures that are definitive. This indicates a necessity to develop methods that lack substantial false positives, by using observables for life that rely on prior hypotheses with strong theoretical and empirical support in identifying defining features of life. theories developed in pursuit of understanding universal features of life are more likely to be definitive and to apply to life-as-we-don't-know-it. We discuss Molecular Assembly theory as an example of such an observable which is applicable to life detection within the solar system. In the absence of alien examples these are best validated in origin of life experiments, substantiating the need for better integration between origins of life and biosignature science research communities. This leads to a conclusion that extraordinary claims in astrobiology ( e.g., definitive detection of alien life) require extraordinary explanations, whereas the evidence itself could be quite ordinary.

Malicious aliens and why Caballero's estimates about them should be rejected

Estimating the prevalence of malicious extraterrestrial civilizations

Deconstructing Alien Hunting

Calculating the probability of detecting radio signals from alien civilizations

MAD with Aliens? Interstellar deterrence and its implications

Aliens on Earth. Are reports of close encounters correct?

Numerical Testing of The Rare Earth Hypothesis using Monte Carlo Realisation Techniques

Research Programs Arising from 'Oumuamua Considered as an Alien Craft

The Number of Possible CETIs within Our Galaxy and the Communication Probability among These CETIs

Upper limits on the probability of an interstellar civilization arising in the local Solar neighborhood

Are Alien Civilizations Technologically Advanced?

Fermi's paradox, extraterrestrial life and the future of humanity: a Bayesian analysis

Qualitative classification of extraterrestrial civilizations

Astronomical Anomalies: Their Role in the Quest for Extraterrestrial Life

Introducing the Exoplanet Escape Factor and the Fishbowl Worlds (Two conceptual tools for the search of extra terrestrial civilizations)

Jamming in granular hopper flow

False Positives and the Challenge of Testing the Alien Hypothesis

On the interstellar origin of high-inclination Centaurs

Are We Special? Humanity and Extraterrestrial Life

The Fermi Paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the Contact Era

EXOPLANET POPULATION INFERENCE AND THE ABUNDANCE OF EARTH ANALOGS FROM NOISY, INCOMPLETE CATALOGS