Jacek Wojtkiewicz,Piotr H. Chankowski
Abstract:According to the `folk knowledge', the Hartree-Fock (H-F) approximation applied to the Hubbard model becomes exact in the limit of small coupling $U$ (the smaller $|U|$, the better is the H-F approximation). In \cite{BP} Bach and Poelchau have substantiated a certain version of this assertion by providing a rigorous estimate of the difference between the true ground-state energy of the simplest version of the Hubbard model and the H-F approximation to this quantity. In this paper we extend their result in two directions: i) we relax the assumption about the strict translational invariance of the hopping matrix, ii) we prove an analogous estimate for a class of multiband Hubbard models.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the difference estimation between the real ground - state energy and the Hartree - Fock (H - F) approximate ground - state energy in the Hubbard model. Specifically, the goal of the paper is to extend the results provided by Bach and Poelchau in reference [1] in two directions:
1. **Relaxing the assumption of strict translational invariance of the hopping matrix**: The original research assumed that the hopping matrix has strict translational invariance, that is, \(t_{x,y}=t_{x - y,0}\). This paper attempts to relax this assumption and consider more general cases.
2. **Similar estimates for the multi - band Hubbard model**: In addition to the single - band Hubbard model, this paper also attempts to prove that similar estimates are applicable to a class of multi - band Hubbard models.
### Background of the paper
The Hubbard model is a simplified but very important model for describing phenomena in strongly correlated electron systems, such as magnetic ordering (ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic), metal - insulator transitions, and high - temperature superconductivity. Although the Hubbard model is a simplified model, it is very difficult to handle mathematically, and exact solutions or strict results are very rare. Therefore, researchers usually use approximate methods to solve the model, among which the Hartree - Fock approximation is the most commonly used.
### Main contributions
1. **Extension of the single - band model**:
- Relaxed the assumption of translational invariance of the hopping matrix, making the model more general.
- Provided a lower - bound estimate of the difference between the real ground - state energy and the H - F approximate ground - state energy in two - dimensional and three - dimensional lattices.
2. **Extension of the multi - band model**:
- Proved that similar estimates are applicable to multi - band Hubbard models, especially the M - band model and the SU(M) - symmetric Hubbard model.
- For these models, introduced one - dimensional and two - dimensional density operators and obtained a lower - bound estimate of the difference by a method similar to that of the single - band model.
### Specific results
- **Two - dimensional lattice**:
- For a two - dimensional square lattice, when the filling is high, due to the singularity of the density of states (DOS) function, the estimation result is more complex, but the finally obtained lower - bound form is:
\[
\frac{\Delta E(n)}{|\Lambda|}\geq - \text{constant}\left(n^{2/3}U^{4/3}(\ln|U| + 1)+n^{1/2}U|\Lambda|^{- 1/4}|\ln(|\Lambda|^{-1/2}| + 1)\right)
\]
- **Three - dimensional lattice**:
- For a three - dimensional cubic lattice, the estimation result is relatively simple, and the lower - bound form is:
\[
\frac{\Delta E(n)}{|\Lambda|}\geq - \text{constant}\left(n^{2/3}U^{4/3}(1+\ln^{2}|U|+\ln|U|)+n^{1/2}U\times O(|\Lambda|^{-1/6})\right)
\]
- **Multi - band model**:
- For the M - band Hubbard model and the SU(M) - symmetric Hubbard model, similar lower - bound estimates were obtained by introducing appropriate projection operators.
### Conclusion
This paper successfully provided a lower - bound estimate of the difference between the real ground - state energy and the H - F approximate ground - state energy in the Hubbard model in more general cases by extending the method of Bach and Poelchau. These results are applicable not only to the single - band model but also to the multi - band model, providing valuable theoretical support for understanding the properties of strongly correlated electron systems.