Nonexistence of motility induced phase separation transition in one dimension

Indranil Mukherjee,Adarsh Raghu,P. K. Mohanty
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21468/SciPostPhys.14.6.165
2023-06-27
Abstract:We introduce and study a model of hardcore particles obeying run-and-tumble dynamics on a one-dimensional lattice, where particles run in either +ve or -ve $x$-direction with an effective speed $v$ and tumble (change their direction of motion) with a constant rate $\omega.$ We show that the coarse-grained dynamics of the system can be mapped to a beads-in-urn model called misanthrope process where particles are identified as urns and vacancies as beads that hop to a neighbouring urn situated in the direction opposite to the current. The hop rate, same as the magnitude of the current, depends on the total number of beads present in the departure and the arrival urn; we calculate it analytically and show that it does not satisfy the criteria required for a phase separation transition. Tumbling is generally detrimental to the stability of jamming; thus, our results for this restricted tumbling model strongly suggest that motility induced phase separation transition can not occur in one dimension.
Statistical Mechanics,Soft Condensed Matter
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is whether a system of self-propelled particles with specific dynamic characteristics in one-dimensional space (Run-and-Tumble Particles, RTPs) will undergo motility-induced phase separation (MIPS). Specifically, the authors study a model of hard-core RTPs moving on a one-dimensional lattice, where these particles move at a fixed speed in the positive or negative x direction and change direction at a constant rate (i.e., "tumble") when assisted by other particles on their right side. The main contribution of the paper is to demonstrate that under such constrained tumbling dynamics, MIPS is theoretically impossible. This conclusion further implies that in any other one-dimensional RTP model, as long as the tumbling frequency is higher, MIPS will also not occur. This contrasts with some previous numerical simulation results that observed MIPS-like inhomogeneous states, but the paper points out that these states are actually long-lived transient phenomena rather than stable phase-separated states. To prove this, the authors map the model to a beads-urn model known as the "misanthrope process" and verify the validity of this mapping through analytical methods and numerical simulations. Ultimately, by analyzing the steady-state properties of the system, the authors conclude that MIPS cannot occur in this model.