Abstract:This paper introduces a new solution concept for non-cooperative games in normal form with no ties and pure strategies: the Perfectly Transparent Equilibrium. The players are rational in all possible worlds and know each other's strategies in all possible worlds, which together we refer to as Perfect Prediction. The anticipation of a player's decision by their opponents is counterfactually dependent on the decision, unlike in Nash Equilibra where the decisions are made independently. The equilibrium, when it exists, is unique and is Pareto optimal. This equilibrium is the normal-form counterpart of the Perfect Prediction Equilibrium; the prediction happens "in another room" rather than in the past. The equilibrium can also be seen as a natural extension of Hofstadter's superrationality to non-symmetric games. Algorithmically, an iterated elimination of non-individually-rational strategy profiles is performed until at most one remains. An equilibrium is a strategy profile that is immune against knowledge of strategies in all possible worlds and rationality in all possible worlds, a stronger concept than common knowledge of rationality but also than common counterfactual belief of rationality. We formalize and contrast the Non-Nashian Decision Theory paradigm, common to this and several other papers, with Causal Decision Theory and Evidential Decision Theory. We define the Perfectly Transparent Equilibrium algorithmically and, when it exists, prove its uniqueness, its Pareto-optimality, and that it coincides with the Hofstadter's Superrationality on symmetric games. We also relate to concepts found in literature such as Individual Rationality, Minimax-Rationalizability, the Correlated Equilibrium. Finally, we specifically discuss inclusion relationships on the special case of symmetric games and contrast them with asymmetric games.

Coherence without Rationality at the Zero Lower Bound

Rational Expectations Models with Higher-Order Beliefs

Quantal Response Equilibrium and Rationalizability: Inside the Black Box

Rationalizing Irrational Beliefs

Bounded rationality for relaxing best response and mutual consistency: the quantal hierarchy model of decision making

Forthcoming in The Economic Journal The Role of Information Revelation in Elimination Contests

Logic and Interactive RAtionality Yearbook 2012

Ex-post core, fine core and rational expectations equilibrium allocations

On the limit points of an infinitely repeated rational expectations equilibrium

A Theory of Bounded Inductive Rationality

On the Effect of Bounded Rationality in Electricity Markets

Are language models rational? The case of coherence norms and belief revision

Coherence of probabilistic constraints on Nash equilibria

Individual Rationality and Market Efficiency

On Equilibrium Existence in a Finite-Agent, Multi-Asset Noisy Rational Expectations Economy

A continuum of path-dependent equilibrium solutions induced by sticky expectations

Expectations, Networks, and Conventions

Monetary Policy, Bounded Rationality, and Incomplete Markets

Rational Expectations Equilibrium

Perfect Prediction in Normal Form: Superrational Thinking Extended to Non-Symmetric Games