Effective multiplicative independence of 3 singular moduli

Yuri Bilu,Sanoli Gun,Emanuele Tron
2024-07-06
Abstract:Pila and Tsimerman proved in 2017 that for every $k$ there exists at most finitely many $k$-tuples $(x_1,\ldots, x_k)$ of distinct non-zero singular moduli with the property "$x_1, \ldots,x_k$ are multiplicatively dependent, but any proper subset of them is multiplicatively independent". The proof was non-effective, using Siegel's lower bound for the Class Number. In 2019 Riffaut obtained an effective version of this result for $k=2$. Moreover, he determined all the instances of $x^my^n\in \mathbb Q^\times$, where $x,y$ are distinct singular moduli and $m,n$ non-zero integers. In this article we obtain a similar result for $k=3$. We show that $x^my^nz^r\in \mathbb Q^\times$ (where $x,y,z$ are distinct singular moduli and $m,n,r$ non-zero integers) implies that the discriminants of $x,y,z$ do not exceed $10^{10}$.
Number Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the effective bounds in terms of multiplicative dependence of three singular moduli. Specifically, in 2017, Pila and Tsimerman proved that for any \(k\), there exist at most finitely many non - zero singular - modulus \(k\)-tuples \((x_1,\ldots,x_k)\) such that there is a multiplicative dependence relationship among these singular moduli, but any proper subset of them is multiplicatively independent. However, their proof was non - effective and used Siegel's lower bound on the class number. In 2019, Riffaut provided effective results for the case of \(k = 2\) and determined all instances of the form \(x^m y^n\in\mathbb{Q}^\times\), where \(x\) and \(y\) are distinct singular moduli, and \(m\) and \(n\) are non - zero integers. The researchers in this paper further advanced the work in this area and obtained similar results for the case of \(k = 3\). They proved that if three distinct non - zero singular moduli \(x,y,z\) satisfy \(x^m y^n z^r\in\mathbb{Q}^\times\), where \(m,n,r\) are non - zero integers, then the discriminants of these three singular moduli will not exceed \(10^{10}\). That is: \[ \max\{|\Delta_x|,|\Delta_y|,|\Delta_z|\}<10^{10}. \] This result not only provides an effective bound for the case of \(k = 3\), but also, like Riffaut's work, gives an explicit limit on the specific discriminants. In addition, the researchers also explored several known special cases, such as rational - type, quadratic - type and cubic - type examples, and believe that there are no other examples except for these cases, but to verify this requires improving the numerical bound \(10^{10}\) in the theorem. In summary, the core problem of this paper is to improve the previous non - effective results by providing an effective upper bound and to specify the range of the discriminants of three singular moduli under the condition of multiplicative dependence.