Market mechanism to enable grid-aware dispatch of Aggregators in radial distribution networks

Nawaf Nazir,Mads Almassalkhi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2207.04528
2022-07-11
Abstract:This paper presents a market-based optimization framework wherein Aggregators can compete for nodal capacity across a distribution feeder and guarantee that allocated flexible capacity cannot cause overloads or congestion. This mechanism, thus, allows Aggregators with allocated capacity to pursue a number of services at the whole-sale market level to maximize revenue of flexible resources. Based on Aggregator bids of capacity (MW) and network access price ($/MW), the distribution system operator (DSO) formulates an optimization problem that prioritizes capacity to the different Aggregators across the network while implicitly considering AC network constraints. This grid-aware allocation is obtained by incorporating a convex inner approximation into the optimization framework that prioritizes hosting capacity to different Aggregators. We adapt concepts from transmission-level capacity market clearing, utility demand charges, and Internet-like bandwidth allocation rules to distribution system operations by incorporating nodal voltage and transformer constraints into the optimization framework. Simulation based results on IEEE distribution networks showcase the effectiveness of the approach.
Optimization and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve The paper aims to address the issue of how aggregators can compete for node capacity in radial distribution networks through market mechanisms, ensuring that the allocated flexible resources do not cause overload or congestion. Specifically, the paper proposes a market-based optimization framework that allows aggregators to compete for node capacity on distribution feeders while ensuring that the allocated flexible resources do not negatively impact the grid. This mechanism allows aggregators to pursue multiple services at the wholesale market level to maximize the revenue from flexible resources. ### Main Research Content 1. **Market Mechanism Design**: - The paper proposes a market mechanism that allows aggregators to bid for node capacity (MW) and network access prices ($/MW). - The distribution system operator (DSO) formulates an optimization problem based on the aggregators' bids, prioritizing the capacity allocation of different aggregators in the network while implicitly considering AC network constraints. 2. **Convex Inner Approximation Method**: - The paper introduces the Convex Inner Approximation (CIA) method, embedding it into the optimization framework to prioritize the carrying capacity of different aggregators. - This method combines concepts from transmission-level capacity market clearing, utility demand charges, and internet bandwidth allocation rules, incorporating node voltage and transformer constraints into the optimization framework. 3. **Dynamic Carrying Capacity**: - The paper aims to determine the dynamic carrying capacity of distribution feeders and how to prioritize node access in a grid-aware manner when multiple aggregators provide flexibility at different locations. - Traditional carrying capacity (HC) methods are usually static, considering worst-case annual demand profiles, which may lead to overly conservative HC values and underutilization of distribution network capacity. 4. **Market Optimization Problem**: - The paper formulates the grid-aware aggregator allocation problem as a convex optimization problem for market clearing, allocating effective carrying capacity based on aggregators' capacity bids (MW, $/MW). - The optimization problem is divided into two steps: the first step checks the feasibility of carrying all aggregators' flexibility, and the second step prioritizes flexibility allocation based on aggregators' bid prices in case of anticipated congestion. ### Case Study - The paper conducts a case study using a modified IEEE-37 node distribution network to demonstrate the effectiveness of the market clearing mechanism. - In the case study, each aggregator's bid includes node capacity (MW) and a fixed capacity price ($/MW). The DSO first solves the feasibility problem (P1) and then solves the optimal allocation problem (P2) in case of anticipated congestion. - The results show that aggregators willing to pay higher prices are allocated more flexible resources, and nodes closer to the substation are prioritized in capacity allocation. ### Summary The paper addresses the issue of effectively managing and allocating flexible resources provided by aggregators in distribution networks through market mechanisms and the Convex Inner Approximation method, ensuring grid safety and reliability while maximizing aggregators' revenue.