Implementing Dependent Types in pi-forall

Stephanie Weirich

2023-07-12

Abstract:These lecture notes describe the design of a minimal dependently-typed language called "pi-forall" and walk through the implementation of its type checker. They are based on lectures given at the Oregon Programming Languages Summer School during July 2023.

Programming Languages

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

WebPie: A Tiny Slice of Dependent Typing

Christophe Scholliers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.400.2

2024-04-08

Abstract:Dependently typed programming languages have become increasingly relevant in recent years. They have been adopted in industrial strength programming languages and have been extremely successful as the basis for theorem provers. There are however, very few entry level introductions to the theory of language constructs for dependently typed languages, and even less sources on didactical implementations. In this paper, we present a small dependently typed programming language called WebPie. The main features of the language are inductive types, recursion and case matching. While none of these features are new, we believe this article can provide a step forward towards the understanding and systematic construction of dependently typed languages for researchers new to dependent types.

Programming Languages,Logic in Computer Science,Symbolic Computation
Dependent Types in Haskell: Theory and Practice

Richard A. Eisenberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1610.07978

2017-08-13

Abstract:Haskell, as implemented in the Glasgow Haskell Compiler (GHC), has been adding new type-level programming features for some time. Many of these features---chiefly: generalized algebraic datatypes (GADTs), type families, kind polymorphism, and promoted datatypes---have brought Haskell to the doorstep of dependent types. Many dependently typed programs can even currently be encoded, but often the constructions are painful. In this dissertation, I describe Dependent Haskell, which supports full dependent types via a backward-compatible extension to today's Haskell. An important contribution of this work is an implementation, in GHC, of a portion of Dependent Haskell, with the rest to follow. The features I have implemented are already released, in GHC 8.0. This dissertation contains several practical examples of Dependent Haskell code, a full description of the differences between Dependent Haskell and today's Haskell, a novel type-safe dependently typed lambda-calculus (called Pico) suitable for use as an intermediate language for compiling Dependent Haskell, and a type inference and elaboration algorithm, Bake, that translates Dependent Haskell to type-correct Pico.

Programming Languages
Embedding Pure Type Systems in the lambda-Pi-calculus modulo

Denis Cousineau,Gilles Dowek

2023-10-19

Abstract:The lambda-Pi-calculus allows to express proofs of minimal predicate logic. It can be extended, in a very simple way, by adding computation rules. This leads to the lambda-Pi-calculus modulo. We show in this paper that this simple extension is surprisingly expressive and, in particular, that all functional Pure Type Systems, such as the system F, or the Calculus of Constructions, can be embedded in it. And, moreover, that this embedding is conservative under termination hypothesis.

Logic in Computer Science
Towards a Direct, By-Need Evaluator for Dependently Typed Languages

David M. Rogers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1509.07036

2015-09-23

Abstract:We present a C-language implementation of the lambda-pi calculus by extending the (call-by-need) stack machine of Ariola, Chang and Felleisen to hold types, using a typeless- tagless- final interpreter strategy. It has the advantage of expressing all operations as folds over terms, including by-need evaluation, recovery of the initial syntax-tree encoding for any term, and eliminating most garbage-collection tasks. These are made possible by a disciplined approach to handling the spine of each term, along with a robust stack-based API. Type inference is not covered in this work, but also derives several advantages from the present stack transformation. Timing and maximum stack space usage results for executing benchmark problems are presented. We discuss how the design choices for this interpreter allow the language to be used as a high-level scripting language for automatic distributed parallel execution of common scientific computing workflows.

Programming Languages
Types, equations, dimensions and the Pi theorem

Nicola Botta,Patrik Jansson,Guilherme Horta Alvares Da Silva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2308.09481

2023-09-04

Abstract:The languages of mathematical physics and modelling are endowed with a rich "grammar of dimensions" that common abstractions of programming languages fail to represent. We propose a dependently typed domain-specific language (embedded in Idris) that captures this grammar. We apply it to explain basic notions of dimensional analysis and Buckingham's Pi theorem. We hope that the language makes mathematical physics more accessible to computer scientists and functional programming more palatable to modelers and physicists.

Programming Languages,Logic in Computer Science
A Probabilistic Dependent Type System based on Non-Deterministic Beta Reduction

Jonathan H. Warrell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.06420

2016-02-24

Abstract:We introduce Probabilistic Dependent Type Systems (PDTS) via a functional language based on a subsystem of intuitionistic type theory including dependent sums and products, which is expanded to include stochastic functions. We provide a sampling-based semantics for the language based on non-deterministic beta reduction. Further, we derive a probabilistic logic from the PDTS introduced as a direct result of the Curry-Howard isomorphism. The probabilistic logic derived is shown to provide a universal representation for finite discrete distributions.

Logic in Computer Science,Programming Languages
A decompilation of the pi-calculus and its application to termination

Roberto Amadio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1102.2339

2011-02-11

Programming Languages

Abstract:We study the correspondence between a concurrent lambda-calculus in administrative, continuation passing style and a pi-calculus and we derive a termination result for the latter.
Stratified Type Theory

Jonathan Chan,Stephanie Weirich

2024-04-07

Abstract:A hierarchy of type universes is a rudimentary ingredient in the type theories of many proof assistants to prevent the logical inconsistency resulting from combining dependent functions and the type-in-type rule. In this work, we argue that a universe hierarchy is not the only option for a type theory with a type universe. Taking inspiration from Leivant's Stratified System F, we introduce Stratified Type Theory (StraTT), where rather than stratifying universes by levels, we stratify typing judgements and restrict the domain of dependent functions to strictly lower levels. Even with type-in-type, this restriction suffices to enforce consistency. In StraTT, we consider a number of extensions beyond just stratified dependent functions. First, the subsystem subStraTT employs McBride's crude-but-effective stratification (also known as displacement) as a simple form of level polymorphism where global definitions with concrete levels can be displaced uniformly to any higher level. Second, to recover some expressivity lost due to the restriction on dependent function domains, the full StraTT includes a separate nondependent function type with a "floating" domain whose level matches that of the overall function type. Finally, we have implemented a prototype type checker for StraTT extended with datatypes and inference for level and displacement annotations, along with a small core library. We have proven subStraTT to be consistent and StraTT to be type safe, but consistency of the full StraTT remains an open problem, largely due to the interaction between floating functions and cumulativity of judgements. Nevertheless, we believe StraTT to be consistent, and as evidence have verified the failure of some well-known type-theoretic paradoxes using our implementation.

Programming Languages
Presburger-Definable Parameterized Typestates

Ashish Mishra,Deepak Dsouza,Y. N. Srikant

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1712.08753

2017-12-23

Programming Languages

Abstract:Typestates are good at capturing dynamic states of a program as compared to normal types that can capture static structural properties of data and program. Although useful, typestates are suitable only for specifying and verifying program properties defined using finite-state abstractions. Many useful dynamic properties of programs are not finite-state definable. To address these issues, we introduce parameterized typestates (p-typestates). p-typestates associate a logical property with each state of regular typestate, thereby allowing specification of properties beyond finite-state abstractions. We present a dependent type system to express and verify p-typestate properties and a typestate-oriented core programming language incorporating these dependent types. Automatic inductive type-checking of p-typestate properties usually requires a programmer to provide loop invariants as annotations. Here we propose a way to calculate loop invariants automatically, using loop acceleration techniques for Presburger definable transition systems. \keywords{Programming Languages, Typestates, Dependent Types, Non-Regular Program Properties, Verification, Loop Invariants}
A Functional Presentation of Pi Calculus

Fu Yuxi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02713937

2001-01-01

Science in China Series F Information Sciences

Abstract:From the very beginning process algebra introduced the dichotomy between channels and processes. This dichotomy prevails in all present process calculi. The situation is in contrast to that with lambda calculus which has only one class of entities—the lambda terms. We introduce in this paper a process calculus called Lamp in which channels are process names. The language is more uniform than existing process calculi in two aspects: First it has a unified treatment of channels and processes. There is only one class of syntactical entities—processes. Second it has a unified presentation of both first order and higher order process calculi. The language is functional in the sense that lambda calculus is functional. Two bisimulation equivalences, barbed and closed bisimilarities, are proved to coincide. A natural translation from Pi calculus to Lamp is shown to preserve both operational and algebraic semantics. The relationship between lazy lambda calculus and Lamp is discussed.
Functional Array Programming in an Extended Pi-Calculus

Hans Hüttel,Lars Jensen,Chris Oliver Paulsen,Julian Teule

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.412.2

2024-11-22

Abstract:We study the data-parallel language BUTF, inspired by the Futhark language for array programming. We give a translation of BUTF into a version of the pi-calculus with broadcasting and labeled names. The translation is both complete and sound. Moreover, we propose a cost model by annotating translated BUTF processes. This is used for a complexity analysis of the translation.

Programming Languages,Logic in Computer Science
Minimal Predicates, Fixed-Points, and Definability

J Van Benthem

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2178/jsl/1122038910

2005-01-01

Abstract:AbstractMinimal predicates P satisfying a given first-order description ϕ(P) occur widely in mathematical logic and computer science. We give an explicit first-order syntax for special first-order ‘PIA conditions’ ϕ(P) which guarantees unique existence of such minimal predicates. Our main technical result is a preservation theorem showing PIA-conditions to be expressively complete for all those first-order formulas that are preserved under a natural model-theoretic operation of ‘predicate intersection’. Next, we show how iterated predicate minimization on PIA-conditions yields a language MIN(FO) equal in expressive power to LFP(FO), first-order logic closed under smallest fixed-points for monotone operations. As a concrete illustration of these notions, we show how our sort of predicate minimization extends the usual frame correspondence theory of modal logic, leading to a proper hierarchy of modal axioms: first-order-definable, first-order fixed-point definable, and beyond.
PIETOOLS: A Matlab Toolbox for Manipulation and Optimization of Partial Integral Operators

Sachin Shivakumar,Amritam Das,Matthew M. Peet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1910.01338

2020-04-30

Abstract:In this paper, we present PIETOOLS, a MATLAB toolbox for the construction and handling of Partial Integral (PI) operators. The toolbox introduces a new class of MATLAB object, opvar, for which standard MATLAB matrix operation syntax (e.g. +, *, ' e tc.) is defined. PI operators are a generalization of bounded linear operators on infinite-dimensional spaces that form a *-subalgebra with two binary operations (addition and composition) on the space RxL2. These operators frequently appear in analysis and control of infinite-dimensional systems such as Partial Differential equations (PDE) and Time-delay systems (TDS). Furthermore, PIETOOLS can: declare opvar decision variables, add operator positivity constraints, declare an objective function, and solve the resulting optimization problem using a syntax similar to the sdpvar class in YALMIP. Use of the resulting Linear Operator Inequalities (LOIs) are demonstrated on several examples, including stability analysis of a PDE, bounding operator norms, and verifying integral inequalities. The result is that PIETOOLS, packaged with SOSTOOLS and MULTIPOLY, offers a scalable, user-friendly and computationally efficient toolbox for parsing, performing algebraic operations, setting up and solving convex optimization problems on PI operators.

Optimization and Control,Dynamical Systems
Primitive Recursive Dependent Type Theory

Ulrik Buchholtz,Johannes Schipp von Branitz

2024-04-01

Abstract:We show that restricting the elimination principle of the natural numbers type in Martin-Löf Type Theory (MLTT) to a universe of types not containing $\Pi$-types ensures that all definable functions are primitive recursive. This extends the concept of primitive recursiveness to general types. We discuss extensions to univalent type theories and other notions of computability. We are inspired by earlier work by Martin Hofmann, work on Joyal's arithmetic universes, and Hugo Herbelin and Ludovic Patey's sketched Calculus of Primitive Recursive Constructions.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
Typed Non-determinism in Functional and Concurrent Calculi

Bas van den Heuvel,Joseph W. N. Paulus,Daniele Nantes-Sobrinho,Jorge A. Pérez

2023-09-29

Abstract:We study functional and concurrent calculi with non-determinism, along with type systems to control resources based on linearity. The interplay between non-determinism and linearity is delicate: careless handling of branches can discard resources meant to be used exactly once. Here we go beyond prior work by considering non-determinism in its standard sense: once a branch is selected, the rest are discarded. Our technical contributions are three-fold. First, we introduce a $\pi$-calculus with non-deterministic choice, governed by session types. Second, we introduce a resource $\lambda$-calculus, governed by intersection types, in which non-determinism concerns fetching of resources from bags. Finally, we connect our two typed non-deterministic calculi via a correct translation.

Logic in Computer Science
Programming with union, intersection, and negation types

Giuseppe Castagna

2024-03-27

Abstract:In this essay, I present the advantages and, I dare say, the beauty of programming in a language with set-theoretic types, that is, types that include union, intersection, and negation type connectives. I show by several examples how set-theoretic types are necessary to type some common programming patterns, but also how they play a key role in typing several language constructs-from branching and pattern matching to function overloading and type-cases-very precisely. I start by presenting the theory of types known as semantic subtyping and extend it to include polymorphic types. Next, I discuss the design of languages that use these types. I start by defining a theoretical framework that covers all the examples given in the first part of the presentation. Since the system of the framework cannot be effectively implemented, I then describe three effective restrictions of this system: (i) a polymorphic language with explicitly-typed functions, (ii) an implicitly-typed polymorphic language à la Hindley-Milner, and (iii) a monomorphic language that, by implementing classic union-elimination, precisely reconstructs intersection types for functions and implements a very general form of occurrence typing. I conclude the presentation with a short overview of other aspects of these languages, such as pattern matching, gradual typing, and denotational semantics.

Programming Languages
Typing Composite Subjects

Luca Aceto,Daniele Gorla,Stian Lybech

2024-11-21

Abstract:Many type systems have been presented in the literature for variants of the pi-calculus, but none of them are able to handle composite subjects such as those found in the language epi, which features polyadic synchronisation. The purpose of this paper is to address the question of how to type composite subjects in a general fashion. We assess the validity of our proposal by first proving the standard correctness results for a type system (i.e., subject reduction and type safety). Then, we follow the path opened by Sangiorgi in 1998 and show an encoding in epi of a minimal OO language called WC (While with \Classes) whose ``expectable'' type system exactly corresponds to the one induced by ours via the encoding. This comparison contributes to understanding the relationship between our types and conventional types for OO languages.

Programming Languages
Free Monads, Intrinsic Scoping, and Higher-Order Preunification

Nikolai Kudasov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2204.05653

2024-02-24

Abstract:Type checking algorithms and theorem provers rely on unification algorithms. In presence of type families or higher-order logic, higher-order (pre)unification (HOU) is required. Many HOU algorithms are expressed in terms of $\lambda$-calculus and require encodings, such as higher-order abstract syntax, which are sometimes not comfortable to work with for language implementors. To facilitate implementations of languages, proof assistants, and theorem provers, we propose a novel approach based on the second-order abstract syntax of Fiore, data types à la carte of Swierstra, and intrinsic scoping of Bird and Patterson. With our approach, an object language is generated freely from a given bifunctor. Then, given an evaluation function and making a few reasonable assumptions on it, we derive a higher-order preunification procedure on terms in the object language. More precisely, we apply a variant of $E$-unification for second-order syntax. Finally, we briefly demonstrate an application of this technique to implement type checking (with type inference) for Martin-Löf Type Theory, a dependent type theory.

Logic in Computer Science
Session Types as Generic Process Types

Simon J. Gay,Nils Gesbert,António Ravara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.160.9

2014-08-07

Abstract:Behavioural type systems ensure more than the usual safety guarantees of static analysis. They are based on the idea of "types-as-processes", providing dedicated type algebras for particular properties, ranging from protocol compatibility to race-freedom, lock-freedom, or even responsiveness. Two successful, although rather different, approaches, are session types and process types. The former allows to specify and verify (distributed) communication protocols using specific type (proof) systems; the latter allows to infer from a system specification a process abstraction on which it is simpler to verify properties, using a generic type (proof) system. What is the relationship between these approaches? Can the generic one subsume the specific one? At what price? And can the former be used as a compiler for the latter? The work presented herein is a step towards answers to such questions. Concretely, we define a stepwise encoding of a pi-calculus with sessions and session types (the system of Gay and Hole) into a pi-calculus with process types (the Generic Type System of Igarashi and Kobayashi). We encode session type environments, polarities (which distinguish session channels end-points), and labelled sums. We show forward and reverse operational correspondences for the encodings, as well as typing correspondences. To faithfully encode session subtyping in process types subtyping, one needs to add to the target language record constructors and new subtyping rules. In conclusion, the programming convenience of session types as protocol abstractions can be combined with the simplicity and power of the pi-calculus, taking advantage in particular of the framework provided by the Generic Type System.

Programming Languages,Logic in Computer Science
Proofs for Free in the $λΠ$-Calculus Modulo Theory

Thomas Traversié

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.404.4

2024-07-09

Abstract:Parametricity allows the transfer of proofs between different implementations of the same data structure. The lambdaPi-calculus modulo theory is an extension of the lambda-calculus with dependent types and user-defined rewrite rules. It is a logical framework, used to exchange proofs between different proof systems. We define an interpretation of theories of the lambdaPi-calculus modulo theory, inspired by parametricity. Such an interpretation allows to transfer proofs for free between theories that feature the notions of proposition and proof, when the source theory can be embedded into the target theory.

Logic in Computer Science

Implementing Dependent Types in pi-forall

WebPie: A Tiny Slice of Dependent Typing

Dependent Types in Haskell: Theory and Practice

Embedding Pure Type Systems in the lambda-Pi-calculus modulo

Towards a Direct, By-Need Evaluator for Dependently Typed Languages

Types, equations, dimensions and the Pi theorem

A Probabilistic Dependent Type System based on Non-Deterministic Beta Reduction

A decompilation of the pi-calculus and its application to termination

Stratified Type Theory

Presburger-Definable Parameterized Typestates

A Functional Presentation of Pi Calculus

Functional Array Programming in an Extended Pi-Calculus

Minimal Predicates, Fixed-Points, and Definability

PIETOOLS: A Matlab Toolbox for Manipulation and Optimization of Partial Integral Operators

Primitive Recursive Dependent Type Theory

Typed Non-determinism in Functional and Concurrent Calculi

Programming with union, intersection, and negation types

Typing Composite Subjects

Free Monads, Intrinsic Scoping, and Higher-Order Preunification

Session Types as Generic Process Types

Proofs for Free in the $λΠ$-Calculus Modulo Theory