Mantle mineralogy limits to rocky planet water inventories

Claire Marie Guimond,Oliver Shorttle,John F. Rudge

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stad148

2023-01-12

Abstract:Nominally anhydrous minerals in rocky planet mantles can sequester oceans of water as a whole, giving a constraint on bulk water inventories. Here we predict mantle water capacities from the thermodynamically-limited solubility of water in their constituent minerals. We report the variability of mantle water capacity due to (i) host star refractory element abundances that set mineralogy, (ii) realistic mantle temperature scenarios, and (iii) planet mass. We find that planets large enough to stabilise perovskite almost unfailingly have a dry lower mantle, topped by a high-water-capacity transition zone which may act as a bottleneck for water transport within the planet's interior. Because the pressure of the ringwoodite-perovskite phase boundary defining the lower mantle is roughly insensitive to planet mass, the relative contribution of the upper mantle reservoir will diminish with increasing planet mass. Large rocky planets therefore have disproportionately small mantle water capacities. In practice, our results would represent initial water concentration profiles in planetary mantles where their primordial magma oceans are water-saturated. We suggest that a considerable proportion of massive rocky planets' accreted water budgets would form surface oceans or atmospheric water vapour immediately after magma ocean solidification, possibly diminishing the likelihood of these planets hosting land. This work is a step towards understanding planetary deep water cycling, thermal evolution as mediated by rheology and melting, and the frequency of waterworlds.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper explores the limitations of water content in the mantles of rocky planets (like Earth) caused by hydrous minerals. The researchers predicted the water capacity of silicate mantles under different conditions, such as stellar elemental abundances, mantle temperatures, and planetary masses. They found that transition zone minerals (such as ringwoodite and perovskite) almost always dominate the mantle water storage in planets with masses less than approximately 1.5 times the mass of Earth, which may limit the transport of deep water. However, this discontinuity is less pronounced when the ratio of magnesium to silicon is lower. As the planetary mass increases, the importance of the upper mantle reservoir decreases, as the pressure boundary remains relatively unchanged.

The paper points out that the distribution of water within a planet not only affects habitability, but also deep water cycling, thermal evolution, and plate tectonics. The study uses experimental and theoretical data to estimate mineral water saturation and considers various possible mantle compositions based on stellar chemical abundances. The findings contribute to understanding the water cycling, thermal evolution, and frequency of "ocean worlds" in exoplanets.

A method is proposed in the paper by converting stellar elemental abundances into a planet's internal water capacity. The study covers calculations from stellar abundances to planetary compositions, then to internal structure and mineralogy to estimate the water capacity of the planet. These calculations are important for understanding planetary water cycling and future habitability studies of exoplanets.