Solar Power Smoothing in a Nanogrid Testbed

Hossein Panamtash,Rubin York,Paul Brooker,Justin Kramer,Qun Zhou Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.15323

2022-06-30

Abstract:High penetration of solar power introduces new challenges in the operation of distribution systems. Considering the highly volatile nature of solar power output due to changes in cloud coverage, maintaining the power balance and operating within ramp rate limits can be an issue. Great benefits can be brought to the grid by smoothing solar power output at individual sites equipped with flexible resources such as electrical vehicles and battery storage systems. This paper proposes several approaches to a solar smoothing application by utilizing battery storage and EV charging control in a "Nanogrid" testbed located at a utility in Florida. The control algorithms focus on both real-time application and predictive control depending on forecasts. The solar smoothing models are then compared using real data from the Nanogrid site to present the effectiveness of the proposed models and compare their results. Furthermore, the control methods are applied to the Orlando Utilities Commission (OUC) Nanogrid to confirm the simulation results.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the challenge posed to the distribution grid operation by the fluctuations in solar power output due to cloud cover changes after a high proportion of solar power generation is integrated into the grid. Specifically, the rapid changes in solar power output can make it difficult to maintain system power balance and exceed the system's ramp rate limits. To address this issue, the paper proposes several methods to smooth solar power output using battery energy storage systems and electric vehicle charging control on the "Nano Grid" test platform.

### Main Research Content:
1. **Background and Problem**:
- After a high proportion of solar power is integrated into the grid, the solar power output fluctuates significantly due to cloud cover and other reasons.
- These fluctuations can make it difficult to maintain system power balance, exceed the system's ramp rate limits, and affect the stable operation of the grid.

2. **Solutions**:
- **Real-time Control**: Based on current solar power output and load data, adjust the battery charge/discharge rate and electric vehicle charging rate in real-time to minimize ramp rate violations.
- **Predictive Control**: Use forecast data of solar power and load to pre-adjust the battery charge/discharge rate and electric vehicle charging rate to cope with future power changes. Predictive control includes two methods:
- **Moving Average Target Curve**: Generate a smooth target curve by smoothing power changes over a future period to reduce ramp rate violations.
- **Variance Target Curve**: Dynamically adjust the target curve based on the variance of future power changes to cope with power fluctuations caused by cloud cover changes.

3. **Experimental Validation**:
- The above control algorithms were applied on the Nano Grid test platform of the Orlando Utilities Commission (OUC) to verify their effectiveness and performance.
- By comparing the effects of different control methods using actual data, their performance in reducing ramp rate violations and managing battery energy storage was evaluated.

### Conclusion:
- The real-time control method can maintain system power within ramp rate limits in most cases, but some violations still occur.
- The predictive control method, by using forecast data, can more effectively reduce ramp rate violations, with the moving average target curve method performing the best.
- Predictive control not only reduces ramp rate violations but also better manages battery energy storage, improving battery charging and discharging efficiency.

In summary, this paper proposes a method that combines real-time control and predictive control to smooth solar power output using battery energy storage and electric vehicle charging control, thereby improving the stability and reliability of the grid.