Permutations with arithmetic constraints

Carl Pomerance
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.01699
2022-06-06
Abstract:Let $S_{\rm lcm}(n)$ denote the set of permutations $\pi$ of $[n]=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ such that ${\rm lcm}[j,\pi(j)]\le n$ for each $j\in[n]$. Further, let $S_{\rm div}(n)$ denote the number of permutations $\pi$ of $[n]$ such that $j\mid\pi(j)$ or $\pi(j)\mid j$ for each $j\in[n]$. Clearly $S_{\rm div}(n)\subset S_{\rm lcm}(n)$. We get upper and lower bounds for the counts of these sets, showing they grow geometrically. We also prove a conjecture from a recent paper on the number of "anti-coprime" permutations of $[n]$, meaning that each $\gcd(j,\pi(j))>1$ except when $j=1$.
Number Theory,Combinatorics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the permutation counting problems related to arithmetic constraints. Specifically: 1. **Define specific permutation sets**: - Define two special permutation sets \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) and \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \), where: - \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) refers to all permutations \( \pi \) such that for each \( j\in [n] \), \( \text{lcm}(j,\pi(j))\leq n \). - \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \) refers to all permutations \( \pi \) such that for each \( j\in [n] \), \( j\mid \pi(j) \) or \( \pi(j)\mid j \). 2. **Study the sizes of these sets**: - The main objective of the paper is to provide upper and lower bound estimates for the number of elements in \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) and \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \). Specifically, the author proves that the number of elements in these two sets grows geometrically as \( n \) increases and gives specific upper and lower bound formulas. 3. **Prove a conjecture**: - The author proves a conjecture about "anti - coprime permutations". For a permutation \( \pi \) of \( n \), if for each \( j\in [n] \), except \( j = 1 \), \( \gcd(j,\pi(j))> 1 \), then the lower bound of the number of such permutations is \( \frac{n!}{(\log n)^{\alpha+o(1)}} \), where \( \alpha = e^{-\gamma} \), and \( \gamma \) is the Euler constant. 4. **Compare \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \) and \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \)**: - The author also studies the relative sizes of \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) and \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \) and proves that \( \frac{\#S_{\text{lcm}}(n)}{\#S_{\text{div}}(n)} \) grows geometrically as \( n \) increases. 5. **Derivation of upper and lower bounds**: - The paper elaborately derives the upper and lower bounds of \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) and gives specific estimated values through complex combinatorial analysis and number - theoretic tools. In summary, this paper mainly focuses on the permutation counting problems with arithmetic constraints, especially the study of the number of elements in \( S_{\text{lcm}}(n) \) and \( S_{\text{div}}(n) \) and their properties. Through strict mathematical derivations, the author not only provides upper and lower bound estimates for these sets but also proves some important conjectures.