Abstract:As researchers increase their efforts to characterize variations in the functional connectome across studies and individuals, concerns about the many sources of nuisance variation present and their impact on resting state fMRI (R-fMRI) measures continue to grow. Although substantial within-site variation can exist, efforts to aggregate data across multiple sites such as the 1000 Functional Connectomes Project (FCP) and International Neuroimaging Data-sharing Initiative (INDI) datasets amplify these concerns. The present work draws upon standardization approaches commonly used in the microarray gene expression literature, and to a lesser extent recent imaging studies, and compares them with respect to their impact on relationships between common R-fMRI measures and nuisance variables (e.g., imaging site, motion), as well as phenotypic variables of interest (age, sex). Standardization approaches differed with regard to whether they were applied post-hoc vs. during pre-processing, and at the individual vs. group level; additionally they varied in whether they addressed additive effects vs. additive+multiplicative effects, and were parametric vs. non-parametric. While all standardization approaches were effective at reducing undesirable relationships with nuisance variables, post-hoc approaches were generally more effective than global signal regression (GSR). Across approaches, correction for additive effects (global mean) appeared to be more important than for multiplicative effects (global SD) for all R-fMRI measures, with the exception of amplitude of low frequency fluctuations (ALFF). Group-level post-hoc standardizations for mean-centering and variance-standardization were found to be advantageous in their ability to avoid the introduction of artifactual relationships with standardization parameters; though results between individual and group-level post-hoc approaches were highly similar overall. While post-hoc standardization procedures drastically increased test–retest (TRT) reliability for ALFF, modest reductions were observed for other measures after post-hoc standardizations—a phenomena likely attributable to the separation of voxel-wise from global differences among subjects (global mean and SD demonstrated moderate TRT reliability for these measures). Finally, the present work calls into question previous observations of increased anatomical specificity for GSR over mean centering, and draws attention to the near equivalence of global and gray matter signal regression.

A Re-defined and Generalized Percent-Overlap-of-Activation Measure for Studies of fMRI Reproducibility and its Use in Identifying Outlier Activation Maps

Assessing Certainty of Activation or Inactivation in Test-Retest fMRI Studies

Quantitative Evaluation of Activation State in Functional Brain Imaging

A practical model-based segmentation approach for improved activation detection in single-subject functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging studies

Assessment and Optimization of Functional MRI Analyses

Test–retest Reliability of Fmri Activation During Prosaccades and Antisaccades

Modified test statistics by inter-voxel variance shrinkage with an application to f MRI.

Assessing Variations in Areal Organization for the Intrinsic Brain: from Fingerprints to Reliability

Introducing Co-Activation Pattern Metrics to Quantify Spontaneous Brain Network Dynamics.

Toward Reliable Characterization of Functional Homogeneity in the Human Brain: Preprocessing, Scan Duration, Imaging Resolution and Computational Space

Novel Machine Learning Approaches for Improving the Reproducibility and Reliability of Functional and Effective Connectivity from Functional MRI

Stability and Localization of inter-individual differences in functional connectivity

When most fMRI connectivity cannot be detected: insights from time course reliability

Standardizing the intrinsic brain: Towards robust measurement of inter-individual variation in 1000 functional connectomes.

Reliability and reproducibility of individual differences in functional connectivity acquired during task and resting state

Functional MRI of auditory verbal working memory: long-term reproducibility analysis

Regional homogeneity approach to fMRI data analysis

Concordance Among Indices of Intrinsic Brain Function:Inter-Individual Variation and Temporal Dynamics Perspectives

Spatiotemporal consistency of local neural activities: A new imaging measure for functional MRI data.

An open science resource for establishing reliability and reproducibility in functional connectomics

Activation Network Mapping for Integration of Heterogeneous Fmri Findings