Extending the Technology Acceptance Model 3 to Incorporate the Phenomenon of Warm-Glow

Antonios Saravanos,Stavros Zervoudakis,Dongnanzi Zheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/info13090429
2022-09-13
Abstract:In this paper, we extend the third evolution of the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM3) to incorporate warm-glow with the aim of understanding the role this phenomenon plays on user adoption decisions. Warm-glow is the feeling of satisfaction or pleasure (or both) that is experienced by individuals after they do something "good" for their fellow human. Two constructs - perceived extrinsic warm-glow (PEWG) and perceived intrinsic warm-glow (PIWG) - were incorporated into the TAM3 model to measure the two dimensions of user-experienced warm-glow, forming what we refer to as the TAM3 + WG model. An experimental approach was taken to evaluate the suitability of the proposed model (i.e., TAM3 + WG). A vignette was created to present users with a hypothetical technology designed to evoke warm-glow in participants. Our TAM3 + WG model was found to be superior in terms of fit to the TAM3 model. Furthermore, the PEWG and PIWG constructs were confirmed to be unique within the original TAM3 model. The findings indicate that the factors that have the greatest influence on consumer decisions are (in decreasing order) perceived usefulness (PU), PIWG, subjective norm (SN), and PEWG. Additionally, a higher PEWG resulted in the technology being perceived as more useful. In other words, both extrinsic and intrinsic warm-glow play a prominent role in user decisions as to whether or not to adopt a particular technology.
Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction,Information Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to add the phenomenon of "warm - glow" to the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM3) in order to understand the role of this phenomenon in users' adoption decisions. Specifically, the paper measures the two dimensions of the warm - glow experienced by users by introducing two constructs - Perceived Extrinsic Warm - Glow (PEWG) and Perceived Intrinsic Warm - Glow (PIWG), and forms the so - called TAM3 + WG model. The research aims to evaluate the applicability of this new model, confirm the uniqueness of the warm - glow constructs, and determine the extent to which warm - glow affects users' decisions on whether to adopt a particular technology. The main objectives of the paper include: 1. Incorporating the two dimensions of warm - glow (PEWG and PIWG) into the TAM3 model. 2. Verifying the validity of this enhanced new model (i.e., TAM3 + WG). 3. Confirming that the warm - glow constructs do not duplicate the roles of other factors in the original TAM3 model. 4. Determining the relative influence of warm - glow in users' technology adoption decisions compared to the original TAM3 factors. Through these objectives, the paper hopes to provide a more comprehensive understanding of how warm - glow affects users' acceptance of technology products regarded as "good". This not only contributes to theoretical development but also provides guidance for practice, especially for organizations and individuals who hope to predict or understand the technology adoption process.