Improved Band Gaps and Structural Properties from Wannier-Fermi-Löwdin Self-Interaction Corrections for Periodic Systems

Ravindra Shinde,Sharma S. R. K. C. Yamijala,Bryan M. Wong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-648X/abc407
2022-03-17
Abstract:The accurate prediction of band gaps and structural properties in periodic systems continues to be one of the central goals of electronic structure theory. However, band gaps obtained from popular exchange-correlation functionals (such as LDA and PBE) are severely underestimated partly due to the spurious self-interaction error (SIE) inherent to these functionals. In this work, we present a new formulation and implementation of Wannier function-derived Fermi-Löwdin (WFL) orbitals for correcting the SIE in periodic systems. Since our approach utilizes a variational minimization of the self-interaction energy with respect to the Wannier charge centers, it is computationally more efficient than the HSE hybrid functional and other self-interaction corrections that require a large number of transformation matrix elements. Calculations on several (17 in total) prototypical molecular solids, semiconductors, and wide-bandgap materials show that our WFL self-interaction correction approach gives better band gaps and bulk moduli compared to semilocal functionals, largely due to the partial removal of self-interaction errors.
Materials Science,Chemical Physics,Computational Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of inaccurate prediction of band gaps and structural properties in periodic systems. Specifically, the paper focuses on the severe underestimation of band gaps caused by the self - interaction error (Self - Interaction Error, SIE) when using common exchange - correlation functionals such as LDA and PBE. To correct this problem, the authors propose a new method, namely using Fermi - Löwdin orbitals derived from Wannier functions to correct the self - interaction error in periodic systems (WFL - SIC). ### Main problems 1. **Band - gap underestimation**: When using semi - local functionals such as LDA and PBE, the band gaps of periodic systems are significantly underestimated. 2. **Self - interaction error**: The self - interaction error existing in these functionals leads to inaccuracies in electronic properties. ### Solutions 1. **Wannier - Fermi - Löwdin self - interaction correction (WFL - SIC)**: - **Wannier functions**: Construct Wannier functions from Bloch states, and these functions are localized in real space. - **Fermi - Löwdin orbitals**: Convert Wannier functions into Fermi - Löwdin orbitals through the Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization method. - **Self - interaction energy minimization**: Obtain more accurate electronic wave functions and densities by variational minimization of self - interaction energy. ### Computational details - **Theoretical derivation**: The construction method of Wannier - Fermi - Löwdin orbitals and their application in periodic systems are derived in detail. - **Computational implementation**: The WFL - SIC method is implemented in the open - source software GPAW, and calculations are carried out using a finite - difference real - space grid. - **Benchmark tests**: The accuracy of the method is verified by calculating the ionization potentials and band gaps of 17 different systems. ### Results and discussion - **Molecular systems**: The ionization potentials of multiple molecules are calculated and compared with experimental results and other computational methods. The results show that the WFL - SIC method has high accuracy. - **Periodic systems**: The bulk moduli and band gaps of various solid materials are calculated. The results indicate that the WFL - SIC method is superior to PBE calculations in most cases and is closer to the experimental values. - **Electronic structure**: The influence of the WFL - SIC method on the electronic band structure of periodic systems is analyzed. The results show that the band gaps are significantly improved, especially for wide - band - gap insulators and semiconductor materials. ### Formulas - **Self - interaction correction energy**: \[ E_{\text{WFL - SIC}}^{\sigma}=-\sum_l\left\{E_{\text{XC}}[\rho_l^{\sigma}, 0]+\frac{1}{2}\int\int dr dr'\frac{\rho_l^{\sigma}(r)\rho_l^{\sigma}(r')}{|r - r'|}\right\} \] - **WFL - SIC potential**: \[ \hat{V}_{\text{WFL - SIC}}=\sum_{n\sigma}\hat{V}_{\text{WFL - SIC}}^{n\sigma}|\phi_{n\sigma}\rangle\langle\phi_{n\sigma}| \] - **Bulk modulus**: \[ B = \frac{1}{V_0}\frac{\partial^2 E}{\partial V^2} \] Through the above methods, the paper successfully improves the prediction accuracy of band gaps and structural properties in periodic systems, especially when dealing with wide - band - gap materials.