Abstract:Assessment of negative affective states is a key component of animal welfare research. In laying hens, excessive fearfulness results in reduced production and increased sensitivity to stress. Fearfulness can be defined as a response to a known threat, but anxiety is a response to an unknown threat and may have similar negative consequences. The open field test and tonic immobility test are commonly applied to measure fearfulness in laying hens. An attention bias test that measured individual hen’s responses to playback of a conspecific alarm call in the presence of food was recently pharmacologically validated using an anxiogenic drug but was confounded by the hen’s typical motionless response in a novel environment. The current study used 56-week old free-range layers to further assess the validity of an attention bias test to differentiate ranging treatment groups in comparison with the open field and tonic immobility tests. The selected hens varied in their range use patterns as tracked by radio-frequency identification technology. ‘Indoor’ hens did not access the range and ‘outdoor’ hens ranged daily; previous research has confirmed higher fearfulness in hens that remain indoors. The tonic immobility test did not differentiate ranging groups ( P = 0.34), but indoor birds were slower to first step ( P = 0.03) and stepped less ( P = 0.02) in the open field test. The attention bias test occurred in an isolated wooden box using a conspecific alarm call playback (a threat) and mixed grain (a positive stimulus). The behavioural response of latency to resume eating following playback of the alarm call was measured to differentiate the anxiety states of the indoor and outdoor ranging birds. Before the attention bias test could occur, birds had to be habituated to the test box across three separate 5-minute sessions to increase the willingness to feed within the novel test environment. All birds ate faster across time ( P < 0.001) but the indoor birds were slower to eat than the outdoor birds ( P < 0.001). In this study, the latency to resume eating following an alarm call was determined to be a poor measure for highly anxious birds as they failed to eat at all. Forty-six percent of indoor hens were excluded for not eating across the 5-minute test. Of the birds that did eat, only 7% of indoor hens ate following playback of the alarm call, compared with 36% of outdoor hens. This repetition of an attention bias test for laying hens highlights the challenges in assessing hens with extreme fearful/anxious responses and that information may be missed when non-performing hens are excluded from behavioural tests. We suggest that latency to eat in a novel arena without any alarm call playback is an informative measure of anxious state that can be applied to all hens but consideration must be made of potential differences in food motivation.

Effects of auditory and physical enrichment on 3 measurements of fear and stress (tonic immobility duration, heterophil to lymphocyte ratio, and fluctuating asymmetry) in several breeds of layer chicks

Effects of Different Auditory Environments on Behavior, Learning Ability, and Fearfulness in 4-Week-Old Laying Hen Chicks

Effect of prenatal different auditory environment on learning ability and fearfulness in chicks

Effect Of Environmental Enrichment On Fearful Behavior And Gastrin-Releasing Peptide Receptor Expression In The Amygdala Of Prenatal Stressed Rats

Effects of a veterinary functional music-based enrichment program on the psychophysiological responses of farm pigs

Prenatal auditory stimulation and impacts on physiological response to feed restriction in broiler chickens at market age

Application of open field, tonic immobility, and attention bias tests to hens with different ranging patterns

Research Note: Effects of environmental sound stimulus on behavioral responses, cortisol levels, and horizontal immunity of transferred pullets

Raising laying hens: housing complexity and genetic strain affect startle reflex amplitude and behavioural response to fear-inducing stimuli

Prenatal auditory stimulation induces physiological stress responses in developing embryos and newly hatched chicks

Long-term music stimulating alleviated the inflammatory responses caused by acute noise stress on the immune organs of broilers by NF-κB signaling pathway

Behavioral effects of environmental enrichment on male and female wistar rats with early life stress experiences

Early experiences matter: a review of the effects of prenatal environment on offspring characteristics in poultry

The effects of auditory enrichment on zebrafish behavior and physiology

Effects of Environmental Enrichment Materials on the Indicators of Broiler Welfare

Commercial hatchery practices have long-lasting effects on laying hens' spatial behaviour and health

Effects of Olfactory and Auditory Enrichment on Heart Rate Variability in Shelter Dogs

Auditory enrichment with different genres of music for colony queens

Effects of Different Stocking Densities on Tracheal Barrier Function and Its Metabolic Changes in Finishing Broilers

An attention bias test to assess anxiety states in laying hens

Differences among domestic chicken breeds in tonic immobility responses as a measure of fearfulness