A critical analysis on the sensitivity enhancement of surface plasmon resonance sensors with graphene

Aline dos S. Almeida,D. A. Bahamon,Nuno M. R. Peres,Christiano J. S. de Matos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/nano12152562

2022-01-28

Abstract:The use of graphene in surface plasmon resonance sensors, covering a metallic (plasmonic) film, has a number of demonstrated advantages, such protecting the film against corrosion/oxidation and facilitating the introduction of functional groups for selective sensing. Recently, a number of works have claimed that few-layer graphene can also increase the sensitivity of the sensor. However, graphene was treated as an isotropic thin film, with an out-of-plane refractive index that is identical to the in-plane index. Here, we critically examine the role of single and few layers of graphene in the sensitivity enhancement of surface plasmon resonance sensors. Graphene is introduced over the metallic film via three different descriptions: as an atomic-thick two-dimensional sheet, as a thin effective isotropic material (same conductivity in the three coordinate directions), and as an non-isotropic layer (different conductivity in the perpendicular direction to the two-dimensional plane). We find that only the isotropic layer model, which is known to be incorrect for the optically modelling of graphene, provides sizeable sensitivity increases, while the other, more accurate, models lead to negligible contribution to the sensitivity.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: whether the application of graphene in Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) sensors can significantly improve the sensitivity of the sensors. Specifically, the authors explored the influence of single - layer or multi - layer graphene under different models on the performance of SPR sensors.

### Research Background
SPR sensors are a highly sensitive, real - time and label - free technology, which are widely used in the fields of chemical and biological sensing. Traditional SPR sensors are usually composed of a thin metal film (such as gold) deposited on a prism, and detect the change of the refractive index of the analyte by monitoring the change of the incident angle. In recent years, some studies have shown that adding graphene on the metal surface can further improve the sensitivity of the sensor, but in these studies, graphene is simply regarded as an isotropic thin film, which may lead to inaccurate results.

### Main Problems
1. **The influence of graphene on the sensitivity of SPR sensors**: The paper aims to evaluate whether graphene can indeed improve the sensitivity of SPR sensors under different modeling methods.
2. **The correct modeling method of graphene**: Whether the assumption that graphene is regarded as an isotropic thin film in the existing literature is reasonable, and the influence of more accurate modeling methods (such as anisotropic or two - dimensional materials) on the results.

### Methods and Findings
The authors modeled graphene in the following three ways:
- **2D Model**: Graphene is regarded as a two - dimensional sheet with atomic thickness.
- **3D Isotropic Model**: Graphene is regarded as an isotropic thin film with the same conductivity.
- **3D Anisotropic Model**: Consider the different conductivities of graphene in - plane and out - of - plane.

The research results show that:
- **Isotropic model**: When graphene is modeled as an isotropic thin film, a significant improvement in sensitivity is indeed observed, but this is considered an unphysical result.
- **2D model and anisotropic model**: These two more accurate modeling methods show that graphene has almost no influence on the sensitivity of SPR sensors.

### Conclusions
The main conclusion of the paper is that only when graphene is wrongly modeled as an isotropic thin film, will the sensitivity of SPR sensors be significantly improved. And more accurate 2D or anisotropic modeling methods show that graphene has almost no contribution to the sensitivity of SPR sensors. Therefore, future research should adopt more accurate modeling methods to evaluate the role of graphene in SPR sensors.

### Formula Summary
- **Fresnel reflection coefficient formula**:
\[
r_{123}=\frac{r_{12}+r_{23}e^{i2\phi_2}}{1 + r_{12}r_{23}e^{i2\phi_2}}
\]
\[
r_{1234}=\frac{(r_{12}+r_{23}e^{i2\phi_2})+(r_{12}r_{23}+e^{i2\phi_2})r_{34}e^{i2\phi_3}}{(1 + r_{12}r_{23}e^{i2\phi_2})+(r_{23}+r_{12}e^{i2\phi_2})r_{34}e^{i2\phi_3}}
\]
- **Reflection coefficient of two - dimensional graphene model**:
\[
r_{23}=\frac{k_{z2}\epsilon_3 - k_{z3}\epsilon_2 + k_{z2}k_{z3}\sigma_g}{\epsilon_0\omega}/\frac{k_{z2}\epsilon_3 + k_{z3}\epsilon_2 + k_{z2}k_{z3}\sigma_g}{\epsilon_0\omega}
\]
- **Refractive index of isotropic three - dimensional model**:
\[
n_g^3=\sqrt{1 + i\frac{\sigma_g}{\epsilon_0\omega d_g}}