OtherTube: Facilitating Content Discovery and Reflection by Exchanging YouTube Recommendations with Strangers

Md Momen Bhuiyan,Carlos Augusto Bautista Isaza,Tanushree Mitra,Sang Won Lee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3491102.3502028
2022-01-28
Abstract:To promote engagement, recommendation algorithms on platforms like YouTube increasingly personalize users' feeds, limiting users' exposure to diverse content and depriving them of opportunities to reflect on their interests compared to others'. In this work, we investigate how exchanging recommendations with strangers can help users discover new content and reflect. We tested this idea by developing OtherTube -- a browser extension for YouTube that displays strangers' personalized YouTube recommendations. OtherTube allows users to (i) create an anonymized profile for social comparison, (ii) share their recommended videos with others, and (iii) browse strangers' YouTube recommendations. We conducted a 10-day-long user study (n=41) followed by a post-study interview (n=11). Our results reveal that users discovered and developed new interests from seeing OtherTube recommendations. We identified user and content characteristics that affect interaction and engagement with exchanged recommendations; for example, younger users interacted more with OtherTube, while the perceived irrelevance of some content discouraged users from watching certain videos. Users reflected on their interests as well as others', recognizing similarities and differences. Our work shows promise for designs leveraging the exchange of personalized recommendations with strangers.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve The problem this paper attempts to solve is: how to facilitate users in discovering new content and reflecting on their own interests by exchanging recommendations from strangers. #### Background Modern social media and content sharing platforms (such as YouTube) primarily personalize user-pushed content through algorithms to increase user engagement. These algorithms typically predict content that users might be interested in based on their past interaction history, thereby limiting users' opportunities to encounter diverse content and trapping them in a "filter bubble," which isolates them from other viewpoints and potentially limits their choices. #### Specific Manifestations of the Problem 1. **Filter Bubble**: Personalized recommendation algorithms lead users to see only content similar to their interests, lacking diversity. 2. **Lack of Self-Reflection**: Users find it difficult to realize the limitations of their content consumption, especially those with low cognitive reflection abilities who are more easily influenced by extreme viewpoints. 3. **Limited Content Discovery**: Users find it hard to discover new and different content that they might be interested in. #### Solution To break this "filter bubble," the paper proposes a browser plugin called OtherTube. OtherTube helps users in the following ways: 1. **Displaying Recommendations from Strangers**: Users can see YouTube recommended videos received by other users. 2. **Creating Anonymous Profiles**: Users can create an anonymous profile for social comparison. 3. **Sharing and Removing Recommended Content**: Users can choose to share or remove their recommended videos. #### Research Methods 1. **User Study**: A 10-day user study was conducted with 41 participants using the OtherTube plugin and filling out daily surveys. 2. **Interviews**: After the study, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 11 participants to gain deeper insights into their experiences and feelings. #### Key Findings 1. **Content Discovery**: Users discovered new interests by browsing recommendations from strangers. 2. **Social Comparison**: Users reflected on their own interests through social comparison, recognizing the uniqueness of their interests and similarities with other users. 3. **Impact of Age and Need for Self-Reflection**: Younger users and those with a lower need for self-reflection were more inclined to browse OtherTube content. ### Conclusion The study shows that exchanging recommendations from strangers can help users discover new content and reflect on their own interests, thereby breaking the "filter bubble." This approach provides valuable insights for designing future systems that promote content diversity and social connection.