Abstract:Background The collection, storage, and analysis of large data sets are relevant in many sectors. Especially in the medical field, the processing of patient data promises great progress in personalized health care. However, it is strictly regulated, such as by the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). These regulations mandate strict data security and data protection and, thus, create major challenges for collecting and using large data sets. Technologies such as federated learning (FL), especially paired with differential privacy (DP) and secure multiparty computation (SMPC), aim to solve these challenges. Objective This scoping review aimed to summarize the current discussion on the legal questions and concerns related to FL systems in medical research. We were particularly interested in whether and to what extent FL applications and training processes are compliant with the GDPR data protection law and whether the use of the aforementioned privacy-enhancing technologies (DP and SMPC) affects this legal compliance. We placed special emphasis on the consequences for medical research and development. Methods We performed a scoping review according to the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews). We reviewed articles on Beck-Online, SSRN, ScienceDirect, arXiv, and Google Scholar published in German or English between 2016 and 2022. We examined 4 questions: whether local and global models are “personal data” as per the GDPR; what the “roles” as defined by the GDPR of various parties in FL are; who controls the data at various stages of the training process; and how, if at all, the use of privacy-enhancing technologies affects these findings. Results We identified and summarized the findings of 56 relevant publications on FL. Local and likely also global models constitute personal data according to the GDPR. FL strengthens data protection but is still vulnerable to a number of attacks and the possibility of data leakage. These concerns can be successfully addressed through the privacy-enhancing technologies SMPC and DP. Conclusions Combining FL with SMPC and DP is necessary to fulfill the legal data protection requirements (GDPR) in medical research dealing with personal data. Even though some technical and legal challenges remain, for example, the possibility of successful attacks on the system, combining FL with SMPC and DP creates enough security to satisfy the legal requirements of the GDPR. This combination thereby provides an attractive technical solution for health institutions willing to collaborate without exposing their data to risk. From a legal perspective, the combination provides enough built-in security measures to satisfy data protection requirements, and from a technical perspective, the combination provides secure systems with comparable performance with centralized machine learning applications.

Report: State of the Art Solutions for Privacy Preserving Machine Learning in the Medical Context

Secure, privacy-preserving and federated machine learning in medical imaging

Privacy-preserving machine learning for healthcare: open challenges and future perspectives

Federated Machine Learning, Privacy-Enhancing Technologies, and Data Protection Laws in Medical Research: Scoping Review

Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning Algorithms for Big Data Systems

Machine Learning in Precision Medicine to Preserve Privacy via Encryption

Privacy Preserving Analytics on Distributed Medical Data

Cryptographic Approaches for Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning

Privacy-Preserving Artificial Intelligence: Application to Precision Medicine

Privacy-Preserving in Medical Image Analysis: A Review of Methods and Applications

Security and Privacy in Machine Learning for Health Systems: Strategies and Challenges

State-of-the-Art Approaches to Enhancing Privacy Preservation of Machine Learning Datasets: A Survey

Preserving Data Privacy in Machine Learning Systems

SecureML: A System for Scalable Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning

End-to-end privacy preserving deep learning on multi-institutional medical imaging

Privacy Preserving Machine Learning: Threats and Solutions

Revolutionizing Medical Data Sharing Using Advanced Privacy Enhancing Technologies: Technical, Legal and Ethical Synthesis

Privacy‐preserving data mining and machine learning in healthcare: Applications, challenges, and solutions

Systematic Review of Privacy-Preserving Distributed Machine Learning From Federated Databases in Health Care

Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning: Methods, Challenges and Directions

Machine learning and genomics: precision medicine vs. patient privacy